Wrangling Not Yet Over on Iraqi Charter
Tuesday, October 4, 2005
BAGHDAD, Oct. 3 -- Two weeks before Iraqis vote on a new constitution, with millions of copies already circulating for voters to study, U.S. Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad is leading a drive for major changes in the charter to try to win crucial Sunni Arab support, according to Shiites, Sunnis and Kurds involved in the last-ditch negotiations.
Khalilzad in recent days agreed to take six Sunni demands to Shiite and Kurdish leaders for intensified negotiations. The demands for changes included some that Sunnis hope would keep political power and natural resources under the control of Iraq's traditionally strong central government, Nasser Janabi, a lead Sunni negotiator, said Monday.
"The six demands are our last suggestions," Janabi said. "We cannot give up any more rights. If they agree on these demands, the marginalized group will take another, positive position on the constitution."
The top U.S. officer in Iraq, Gen. George W. Casey, last week warned that if Sunni demands on the charter were frozen out, the Sunni-led insurgency could grow worse. Casey told reporters in Washington that the draft constitution as written jeopardized U.S. hopes for an early spring start to American troop withdrawals.
Khalilzad went to the Kurdish north late last week to urge charter changes on top Kurdish leaders, negotiators said. But neither Shiite nor Kurdish leaders have yet agreed to any of the changes, said both Shiite negotiator Ali Debagh and Kurdish negotiator Mahmoud Othman.
U.S. Embassy officials declined to comment on negotiators' account of the last-minute mediating by the American ambassador, who has pressed and cajoled political leaders for compromise on the charter since taking up his post this past summer.
Iraqis are due to vote on the new constitution Oct. 15. Promoters of the vote have prepared DVDs, pamphlets and forums to outline the charter to the public beforehand.
The draft constitution as written would allow Iraq's newly empowered Shiites and Kurds the option of transforming the nation into a loose federation, including a separate Kurdish north and potentially a separate Shiite south. Many Sunni Arabs, who had wielded tight control from Baghdad since Iraq's creation despite being a minority, said this would mean the breakup of the country.
Iraqi leaders pronounced the draft charter complete on Aug. 28, after three months of closed-door dealmaking and at least three missed deadlines. But Sunni negotiators condemned the draft, saying Kurds and Shiites had opted to try to ram the document through a national vote without their minority's support.
Khalilzad kept up behind-the-scenes negotiations even then to urge initially minor changes in hopes of bringing Sunnis on board. U.N. officials had to wait three more weeks before an official, final version was ready for a $2 million print run to let Iraqis see the draft charter before the vote. Iraqi bloggers joked that the constitution should be stored on a PowerPoint presentation to make changes easier.
Casey, speaking last week at a Pentagon news conference alongside Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld, said his prediction in July that substantial U.S. troop withdrawals could start in early spring had been based on the assumption of continued progress in security and stability in Iraq.
"Now this constitution has come out, and it didn't come out as the national compact that we thought it was going to be," Casey said. "And there's division there . . . and that caused the situation to change a little bit."