Senators Say Alito Respects Roe Decision

The Associated Press
Tuesday, November 8, 2005; 9:11 PM

WASHINGTON -- Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito expressed "great respect" for the precedent established by the landmark Roe v. Wade abortion decision but didn't commit to upholding it, senators said Tuesday as Alito began a second week courting their support.

Sens. Joe Lieberman, D-Conn., and Susan Collins, R-Maine, both used the word "respect" when describing the 55-year-old federal appellate judge's discussions with them on the 1973 ruling that established abortion rights.

Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito, right, speaks with Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kan., left, Tuesday, Nov. 8, 2005 in Brownback's Capitol Hill office in Washington. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh)
Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito, right, speaks with Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kan., left, Tuesday, Nov. 8, 2005 in Brownback's Capitol Hill office in Washington. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh) (Susan Walsh - AP)

Alito said "Roe was precedent on which people, a lot of people, relied and had been precedent now for decades and therefore deserved great respect," Lieberman told reporters after his private meeting with the judge.

Collins said she quizzed Alito on whether it would make a difference if he disagreed with a Supreme Court decision that had been upheld by other judges repeatedly.

"I was obviously referring to Roe in that question," she said. "He assured me that he has tremendous respect for precedent and that his approach is to not overturn cases due to a disagreement with how they were originally decided."

Abortion will be a key topic at the conservative judge's confirmation hearing in January.

President Bush last week selected Alito, a former Reagan administration lawyer who is currently a judge on the Philadelphia-based 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, after White House counsel Harriet Miers withdrew her nomination amid withering criticism from conservatives.

The Senate Judiciary Committee has already set his confirmation hearing for Jan. 9, although Alito has yet to be officially nominated by the White House. He is being nominated to replace retiring Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, who has been a key vote on contentious issues like abortion and affirmative action.

He already has met opposition from abortion rights groups like Planned Parenthood and NARAL Pro-Choice America, who point to an opinion he wrote as a judge on the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals holding that states can require women seeking abortions to notify their spouses. The Supreme Court disagreed.

Lieberman called his meeting with Alito "encouraging," but also said the federal judge had not assured him that he would not overturn Roe. But reading his decisions, "you don't find ideology screaming off the page," Lieberman said.

Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kan., one of the Senate's most strident anti-abortion advocates, said he did not discuss Roe v. Wade with Alito in their meeting. Alito also did not say whether he thinks there is a right to privacy in the Constitution, Brownback said, although the conservative judge has told other senators that he does.

"He did articulate that he thinks one should look at the Constitution as the document is set and try to interpret from that document, not trying to bring in things or seeing it as a living document," said Brownback, who will be one of the senators quizzing Alito at his Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing.

Another Judiciary Committee senator, Massachusetts Democrat Edward M. Kennedy, sent Alito a letter Tuesday asking him for information about his recusal polices involving the Vanguard companies.

Alito owns shares in 14 Vanguard Group mutual funds, with a combined worth of $455,000 to $1.05 million, documents show.

He was hit with a conflict of interest complaint in 2003 after a three-judge panel on which he served dismissed an appeal of a lower court ruling favorable to the Vanguard Group. Alito disqualified himself from further involvement in the case, and another three-judge panel dismissed it.

Alito isn't using his time to just talk about weighty constitutional issues. He also found time to get into a little baseball talk last week with former Philadelphia Phillies pitcher Jim Bunning, now a Republican senator from Kentucky.

Bunning said Tuesday that Alito had told him how he had been a lifelong fan of the club. In fact, a 14-year-old Alito watched the 1964 Phillies collapse after having held first place in the National League for much of the summer, losing 10 straight games and missing the World Series.

Bunning finished that season with a 19-8 record and a 2.63 earned run average.

"He proceeded to tell me about the 1964 season and how we blew the pennant," Bunning said.


Associated Press writers Sam Hananel, Andrew Miga, Jonathan M. Katz and Elizabeth White contributed to this report.

On the Net:

Supreme Court:

Senate Judiciary Committee:

© 2005 The Associated Press