Tokyo Maverick Just One of the Crowd Now
Sunday, November 13, 2005
TOKYO -- Shintaro Ishihara, governor of one of the world's most populous cities, sat comfortably in a white leather armchair in his private meeting room, the endless steel and neon of Greater Tokyo visible behind him through wall-length windows.
Despite the grandeur of his surroundings, Ishihara, 73, no longer seems the threat he once was, when critics feared he would climb to the top job of prime minister and rebuild Japan into a military power. His political ambitions tempered, the nationalist firebrand appears content anyway.
These days, Japan is heading in a direction that Ishihara approves of, even if he is not the one leading the way. Ishihara describes Japanese aggression during World War II as the start of Asia's movement toward independence from the West. He is seen as the precursor of the new crop of hawkish leaders, who may be more diplomatic than Ishihara but appear cut from the same ideological cloth.
Case in point: Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi's new cabinet, announced this past week, includes several politicians who would do the sharp-tongued governor of Tokyo proud. Japan's new foreign minister, Taro Aso, caused a stir in May 2003 when he insisted that Koreans took Japanese names during Japan's 1910-45 colonial rule of the Korean Peninsula because they wanted to. Shinzo Abe, the powerful new cabinet chief whom many analysts describe as Koizumi's anointed successor, is considered a strong-willed nationalist who coyly dodged a question by a foreign reporter in September about whether he regretted Japan's defeat in World War II.
As for Koizumi, Ishihara strongly defends the prime minister's visits to Yasukuni Shrine, which honors Japan's military dead, including World War II criminals. Koizumi's visits have drawn criticism from China and South Korea, along with charges that Japan has not repented of its war crimes.
Ishihara proudly notes that he has made highly publicized visits to Yasukuni for years, and he dismisses the complaints from other Asian countries as signs of their "envy" of Japan.
Ishihara was elected governor six years ago, employing nationalist rhetoric that seemed provocative then. Now it appears he was merely ahead of his time.
Ishihara smiled modestly at the suggestion. "Hmm . . . it might be" true, he said.
While some still see him as a loose cannon, his politics can no longer be called radical. The Mainichi newspaper recently released results of a poll of 1,058 Japanese showing that 43 percent thought the nation's actions during World War II were "clearly wrong," while a majority of respondents either said the war had been unavoidable or were unsure. Meanwhile, revisionist textbooks that critics say whitewash Japan's wartime role are being adopted by more and more schools, and the ruling Liberal Democratic Party is pushing to alter the pacifist postwar constitution to allow an official military.
Ishihara seems satisfied with his role as a trailblazer, the man who long ago said out loud what others privately thought. "Ishihara wasn't just saying it six years ago, he was saying it 30 years ago," said Hisahiko Okazaki, a former Japanese diplomat and analyst. "Ishihara is not an academic. His logic is more propagandist. But with the decline of the left in Japan, his emotion of nationalism is now widely shared by the Japanese people."
This doesn't mean Ishihara has ceased being provocative, although his position may have subtly changed. A novelist and nonfiction writer perhaps best known for his 1989 bestseller, "The Japan That Can Say No," Ishihara was once a powerful critic of Japan's passive stance toward the United States. He still has complaints; he is furious, for instance, that troop realignment talks with the U.S. government have yet to address his plan to use the U.S. air base in Greater Tokyo, Yokota, as a civilian airport. But Ishihara's anti-Americanism appears to have softened as Asian criticism of Japan mounts and the United States remains the country's strongest ally.
That is particularly true as China's rapid rise poses a threat to Japan's economic and diplomatic domination of the region. It is a topic that weighs heavily on Ishihara's mind.