Class Struggle Plagues Terps
Foursome Fails to Realize Potential

By Eric Prisbell
Washington Post Staff Writer
Wednesday, January 25, 2006

After Saturday's victory over Virginia Tech, Chris McCray exited Maryland's locker room and approached a few ushers in the Comcast Center hallway. In a symbolic gesture, he shook each of their hands. Then he bundled up, walked down a long corridor and left. Alone.

This was McCray's unofficial farewell to the Maryland program; two days later, he was ruled academically ineligible. The news was a devastating blow to Maryland's season and the latest setback for a four-player class that once was projected as heirs to the success of the Terrapins' 2002 national championship team but now appears destined to be remembered mostly for its struggles on and off the court since it won the 2004 ACC tournament title.

When they arrived in the fall of 2002, McCray, Travis Garrison, Nik Caner-Medley and John Gilchrist were showered with adulation and seemed ready to take over from a group that made consecutive Final Four appearances. In the past two years, though, three have been arrested, and the fourth, Gilchrist, clashed so often with Coach Gary Williams that Williams called him the most difficult player he has ever coached.

When asked in a telephone interview about the class of 2006, Williams said: "I'm disappointed. But when you look at it, there are probably a few other college students on this campus that have been involved in the same situations. That's not an excuse, and you hope that they will be productive when they leave here because, whatever their experience has been, hopefully they see the right way to go. In recruiting, you try to do as much as you can background-wise before you take a player. These guys all had good backgrounds."

Williams said he wants to see what the four seniors are doing "five or six years from now" before he makes a judgment on the success of the class.

The 18th-ranked Terrapins (13-4, 3-2 ACC) will play without McCray beginning tonight, when they visit a Georgia Tech team (9-7, 2-3) that has struggled of late. The two remaining members of the original class will attempt another step toward returning to the NCAA tournament after Maryland missed it last season for the first time since 1993.

Arrival of 'Rock Stars'

In October 2002, the four-man class arrived in College Park with such fanfare Williams said they were treated like "rock stars." In fact, McCray told reporters after the team's Midnight Madness that he was surprised how fans adored the newcomers even though they had yet to attempt a shot.

"Guys like Juan Dixon, Lonny Baxter, Byron Mouton, Chris Wilcox, Steve Blake, they were good guys," Williams said. "People liked them. They were regular guys. Even though they won the national championship, it didn't change the type of people they were. People welcomed the class after that with open arms because of that."

The class featured four players ranked among the top 100 high school seniors nationally, including Garrison, who was named a McDonald's All-American after his senior season at DeMatha High.

"Most of the teams in the league would have been ecstatic to have a recruiting class with those four guys in it at the time," recruiting analyst Dave Telep said. "And at different points in their careers, each one of those guys has made a contribution to this basketball program. In retrospect, it was a good group that probably never meshed together and, as a result, probably did not max itself out as a recruiting class."

At first, there seemed to be harmony. In 2003, Gilchrist said of Williams: "Coach knows best. He is the one who is the Mozart of this offense and this team. . . . You've got to put your own basketball knowledge aside because he knows more."

The freshmen helped the team reach the NCAA tournament's round of 16 in 2003. The following season they became the core of the team and led the Terps to their first ACC tournament title in 20 years. Gilchrist, who never again had a brighter three-day stretch, was named the tournament's MVP. After a second-round loss to Syracuse in the NCAA tournament, however, trouble soon arose.

Problems Multiply

Caner-Medley was arrested in July 2004 after an incident in the bar district of his home town of Portland, Maine, and he was charged with one misdemeanor count of disorderly conduct. He later agreed to a one-year "filing period," which meant that the charge would not remain on his record as long as he had no criminal or civic violations the following year.

Later that summer, Williams said, the team's trip to Italy for a series of exhibition games offered him a glimpse into how disruptive Gilchrist would be to the team's chemistry. Williams said he regrets not taking a harsher stance with Gilchrist before the 2004-05 season.

In regular season games, Maryland was as inconsistent as any team Williams had ever coached. The Terrapins played hard enough to beat Duke twice but admittedly lacked effort in losses to lesser programs such as Clemson and Miami. Chemistry frayed as the season wore on, in part, a team source said, because the team did not possess a player who would stand up to Gilchrist.

Last spring, Gilchrist, who was not wanted back on the team and did not wish to return to school, declared for the NBA draft but went undrafted. In a visit with a reporter in the spring, he criticized his former teammates for not always matching his intensity in practice and characterized his relationship with Williams as nonexistent.

With Gilchrist now playing professionally in Israel, this season's Terrapins were expected to flourish, particularly with McCray as one of the leaders. He was viewed within the program almost as the anti-Gilchrist, extremely consistent and team-oriented.

But McCray was arrested in August after police said he refused to leave the scene of a fight and initially resisted arrest following an early-morning incident in College Park. He was charged with misdemeanor counts of disturbing the peace, resisting arrest and escaping from custody. Those charges were dropped in mid-October, when McCray agreed to take an alcohol education course offered through the school and serve some 20 hours of community service.

Next came Garrison's arrest following an Oct. 27 incident in a College Park bar. He is accused of grabbing a woman's buttocks three times and, when she protested, slapping her face with an open hand, splitting open her lip, according to police charging documents. Williams suspended Garrison on Jan. 14 for one game, against Wake Forest, for being at the bar, a violation of a team rule. Garrison awaits trial in early April after being charged with second-degree assault and a fourth-degree sex offense, both misdemeanors.

Finally, McCray's career was ruled over Monday, and a season that began with optimism might end with a class being saddled with a legacy worse than missing NCAA tournaments.

"When you put together a good recruiting class," Telep said, "you anticipate losing someone early, so the Gilchrist thing, that's something you anticipate. The McCray part is the most disappointing because not in your wildest dreams when you sign a guy do you think you're going to lose him for the second half of his senior year."

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

© 2006 The Washington Post Company