School Board Criticized in Building Deal
Wednesday, February 15, 2006
The Montgomery County school system misled the public two years ago when it proposed tearing down Seven Locks Elementary School and rebuilding it on another site, according to a county inspector general's report.
In 2004, the County Council agreed with the school board and Superintendent Jerry D. Weast to relocate the aging school, a move that system officials said was cheaper than adding onto and renovating the building at Seven Locks Road in Bethesda.
The council approved a plan to spend $14 million to build the replacement school on Kendale Road about 1 1/2 miles away. Some residents have long suspected that the real motivation was to sell the prime Seven Locks lot to developers. At the time, Weast and County Executive Douglas M. Duncan (D) were considering using the property to increase the county's supply of affordable housing.
Inspector General Thomas Dagley, whose report will be released today, said the school system presented incomplete cost-benefit numbers to the County Council. He also said the school system misrepresented the extent of public support, ignored a cheaper option and awarded a no-bid architectural contract worth $817,014.
Dagley, who is charged with investigating waste and fraud in county government, declined to comment until his report is officially released. A draft of his report, obtained by The Washington Post, outlines a series of possible missteps that call into question how school officials handled the project.
Weast was out ill yesterday and unavailable to comment on the report, according to the school system. But other school officials dismissed Dagley's audit, saying it is flawed. They also challenged the inspector general's authority to investigate how the school board makes decisions.
"I do not believe it was appropriate for you to decide unilaterally to resolve these complaints," school board member Stephen N. Abrams (Rockville-Potomac), citing legal precedence, wrote to Dagley last week in a letter responding to a draft copy of the document.
Several County Council members are calling for further investigation, saying Dagley's findings raise broad questions about how the school system manages its $1.8 billion annual budget.
"It makes you wonder what else is out there," said council member Howard A. Denis (R-Potomac-Bethesda).
Dagley's report contends that the school system selectively used data to conclude that it was too expensive to renovate the existing school building.
And when school officials presented two options to the council -- adding to the existing building or rebuilding the school on Kendale Road -- they said the county would save $3 million by moving the school.
Dagley said school officials did not provide to the council information about a third, less-costly option: demolishing the existing building and then rebuilding on the same site. That would have been about $150,000 cheaper than moving the school, Dagley wrote.