Mass. Marks Health-Care Milestone
Thursday, April 13, 2006
BOSTON, April 12 -- In a Colonial-era hall, with a fife-and-drum corps marching in with him, Gov. Mitt Romney (R) signed a bill Wednesday requiring all Massachusetts residents to purchase health insurance -- portraying the measure as a historic solution to health-care costs, even as questions emerge about whether the state can afford it.
The signing, staged with a near-presidential attention to theatrics and slogan-bearing banners, made Massachusetts the first state to treat health insurance like car insurance, mandating that everyone must have it and fining those who do not.
For that, the bill was praised by a parade of speakers, each seeking the right Revolutionary metaphor.
"You may well have fired a shot heard round the world," said Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.), following a theme that began with the venue, Boston's Faneuil Hall, a gathering place for American patriots.
But, even amid the pomp, the bloom on Massachusetts's first-of-its-kind policy was wearing off. Some observers have charged that the plan promises a huge array of low-cost, state-subsidized health-insurance policies for the uninsured to buy -- but provides few details about how this will be done.
Specifically, the bill leaves much of the detailed work of creating these policies, including setting premiums, co-payments and the required state subsidies, to a "Connector" agency now being created.
That has left state officials with only a rough guess as to how much the system will cost -- perhaps $600 million -- and how much government will have available to pay. The money is supposed to be drawn from funds that are now used to pay for free care for the uninsured, a total estimated by the state at $1 billion.
Alan Sager, a professor at Boston University's School of Public Health, said this week that this kind of financial estimation isn't good enough for a project with such high stakes.
"That's a reckless gamble," he said, adding that the actual cost could far exceed the state's ability to pay. "This bill could do great harm if it de-legitimizes state reform efforts the way the Clinton plan, in '93-'94, de-legitimized federal efforts."
Other observers agreed that there is uncertainty about how the measure will be paid for but saw a bright side: Massachusetts leaders have already reached bipartisan consensus, which few other states have.
"They've done the heavy political lifting," said Ken Thorpe, a professor of health policy at Emory University in Atlanta. He added, however: "It's going to be interesting to see, when the details come out, whether they can hold the support together."
That kind of concern began to emerge Wednesday, amid a ceremony that seemed to set new records for state-level stagecraft. With busts of both presidents Adams looking on, Romney, Kennedy and others walked into the hall behind the musicians of the Revolutionary-reenactor Bostonia Allarum Companie. The bill was laid open by a blue-uniformed, gold-braid-bedecked member of a local historic militia company, beside a quill pen and inkwell.