A May 16 Health article gave incorrect publication information about a study on teenagers' emotional responses to sexual experiences. The study, by Lydia Shrier, an assistant professor of pediatrics at Harvard Medical School, was presented in March at the annual meeting of the Society for Adolescent Medicine. An abstract, not the study itself, was published in the February 2006 issue of the Journal of Adolescent Health.
Is Teen Sex Bad?
Tuesday, May 16, 2006
In our bicultural household -- I am American, my husband is Swedish -- we are trying to raise our children with the language, cultures and values of both countries. In most cases this isn't difficult. In one area, however, our values differ widely: My husband, reflecting the predominant view in Sweden and much of Western Europe, thinks sex is a normal part of adolescent development. Like many in this country, I disagree, believing it's better for teens to wait -- if not until marriage, at least until they are in an adult, loving relationship.
As a health journalist, I wondered if one way of thinking is demonstrably healthier, physically and psychologically. I resolved to find out.
Among the findings that surprised me: Although prevalent attitudes on teen sex differ in Western Europe and the United States, the views of leading researchers and doctors on both sides of the Atlantic do not. Their opinions lean much closer to the European model. They tend to agree that the mixed message America sends to teens about sex -- authorities say "don't" while mass media screams "What are you waiting for?"-- endanger our children.
The outcome? Levels of teen sexual activity look remarkably similar here and abroad, but U.S. rates of teen pregnancy, childbirth, abortion and sexually transmitted diseases are among the highest of all industrialized nations, despite recent decreases. Read brief accounts of how Western European and American perspectives compare.