A Protest By Design, Leading to a War of Words
A handful of designers snubbed Laura Bush last week when she hosted a breakfast for the winners of the National Design Awards. Five honorees in the graphic design category skipped the July 10 gathering and sent the first lady a letter saying they were "compelled to respectfully decline." Their beef? Good design means "words and images must be used responsibly, especially when the matters articulated are of vital importance to the life of our nation" -- and they felt the Bush administration had "seriously harmed" political discourse.
"If you see this as an act of resistance, it's a pretty minor one," said awardee Michael Rock , a partner at the New York firm 2x4 and a professor of design at Yale University School of Art. While honored by the prestigious award (the design Oscars) from Cooper-Hewitt National Design Museum, Rock said yesterday he's professionally offended by the president's "cavalier" use of Sept. 11 imagery in campaign ads, fake news columns and newscasts, and the suppression of "returning war casualties." He and his fellow designers will pick up their prizes in October at the museum gala.
Michael Bierut wrote about the flap on industry blog Design Observer, hoping to stimulate a thoughtful debate about artistic responsibility and protest. Instead, a flurry of vitriolic comments:
From there, the news predictably leapt into the blogosphere, where conservatives and liberals have been slugging it out on the subject for a week, much as they did in 2003 after the first lady canceled a White House poetry symposium when some invitees announced plans to read antiwar poems at the event.
Yesterday the first lady's spokeswoman, Susan Whitson , declined to comment because she has not seen the letter.
Said Bierut yesterday: "I thought at the outset that this was a particularly subtle issue with good, articulate arguments on either side, and was chagrined to see how quickly it escalated (or degenerated) into the usual screaming. If the future of political discourse lies in the blogosphere, as some people claim, be very afraid."
GET THIS!
She's Standing by Her Fish Story
![]() |
| (Scott Minor) |
QUOTED
"There's nobody in the world like me. I think every decade has an iconic blonde -- like Marilyn Monroe or Princess Diana -- and right now, I'm that icon."
-- Paris Hilton, somberly assessing her place in history for the Times of London



