More news from:  Science  |  Environment  |  Health
DISPATCH FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN BEHAVIOR

Two Views of the Same News Find Opposite Biases

Members of the media trailed Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat  --  shown with a refugee child  --  everywhere he went after Israel invaded Lebanon in 1982. That conflict led to some of the first studies of perception of bias. At top right, an Israeli airstrike on Beirut that year. At bottom right, two militants in Beirut fire on Israeli soldiers in 1982.
Members of the media trailed Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat -- shown with a refugee child -- everywhere he went after Israel invaded Lebanon in 1982. That conflict led to some of the first studies of perception of bias. At top right, an Israeli airstrike on Beirut that year. At bottom right, two militants in Beirut fire on Israeli soldiers in 1982. (By Mourad Abdel Raouf -- Associated Press)

Network News

X Profile
View More Activity
By Shankar Vedantam
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, July 24, 2006

You could be forgiven for thinking the television images in the experiment were from 2006. They were really from 1982: Israeli forces were clashing with Arab militants in Lebanon. The world was watching, charges were flying, and the air was thick with grievance, hurt and outrage.

There was only one thing on which pro-Israeli and pro-Arab audiences agreed. Both were certain that media coverage in the United States was hopelessly biased in favor of the other side.

The endlessly recursive conflict in the Middle East provides any number of instructive morals about human nature, but it also offers a psychological window into the world of partisan behavior. Israel's 1982 war in Lebanon sparked some of the earliest experiments into why people reach dramatically different conclusions about the same events.

The results say a lot about partisan behavior in general -- why Republicans and Democrats love to hate each other, for example, or why Coke and Pepsi fans clash. Sadly, the results also say a lot about the newest conflicts between Israel and its enemies in Lebanon and the Palestinian territories, and why news organizations are being besieged with angry complaints from both sides.

Partisans, it turns out, don't just arrive at different conclusions; they see entirely different worlds . In one especially telling experiment, researchers showed 144 observers six television news segments about Israel's 1982 war with Lebanon.

Pro-Arab viewers heard 42 references that painted Israel in a positive light and 26 references that painted Israel unfavorably.

Pro-Israeli viewers, who watched the very same clips, spotted 16 references that painted Israel positively and 57 references that painted Israel negatively.

Both groups were certain they were right and that the other side didn't know what it was talking about.

The tendency to see bias in the news -- now the raison d'etre of much of the blogosphere -- is such a reliable indicator of partisan thinking that researchers coined a term, "hostile media effect," to describe the sincere belief among partisans that news reports are painting them in the worst possible light.

Were pro-Israeli and pro-Arab viewers who were especially knowledgeable about the conflict immune from such distortions? Amazingly, it turned out to be exactly the opposite, Stanford psychologist Lee D. Ross said. The best-informed partisans were the most likely to see bias against their side.

Ross thinks this is because partisans often feel the news lacks context. Instead of just showing a missile killing civilians, in other words, partisans on both sides want the news to explain the history of events that prompted -- and could have justified -- the missile. The more knowledgeable people are, the more context they find missing.

Even more curious, the hostile media effect seems to apply only to news sources that strive for balance. News reports from obviously biased sources usually draw fewer charges of bias. Partisans, it turns out, find it easier to countenance obvious propaganda than news accounts that explore both sides.


CONTINUED     1        >

© 2006 The Washington Post Company

Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity