Islam and the Pope's Choice of Words

Since Sept. 12, 2001, Islamic leaders have cautioned the world not to confuse radical Islam with greater Islam, a religion of peace. Most of us prefer to believe that Islam is a faith deserving universal respect and understanding.

The latest expression of Muslim outrage, this time over Pope Benedict XVI's use of an ancient quotation, appears to come from mainstream Muslims and their leadership, not from hidden dens of jihadists. This violent indignation gives pause when taken with Islam's muted condemnation of the worldwide horrors incited and perpetrated by a growing number of Muslims.

The violent response to a 14th-century emperor's allegation of Islamic intolerance sends a troubling message. Actions speak louder than words. When events consistently belie claims, the hypocrisy diminishes Islam's moral authority. For any religion, visceral outrage is hardly the path of peace and enlightenment.

PETER E. DYKHUIS

Raleigh, N.C.

·

I am writing as a graduate of a fine education in Reform Judaism, as a student of Buddhism and, above all, as a world citizen.

Pope Benedict XVI's citation of a 14th-century ruler's negative evaluation of the prophet Muhammad was, first of all, anachronistic. What relevance does the quotation have to current realities? Second, in view of the centuries darkened by the Crusades, the Spanish Inquisition and the Catholic Church's silence in the face of Hitler's genocide (for which enlightened Catholic leaders have since apologized), the pope's decrying of Islamic violence is the epitome of hypocrisy.

The pope has since claimed -- disingenuously, I believe -- that his citation of an ancient text does not reflect his views. Yet, since his address did not refute the text, why else would he cite it?

In this strife-ridden world, we hardly need more troublemakers. We look to spiritual leaders to be peacemakers.

Oh, Gandhi, where art thou?

INGRID KOMAR