Drugs Used in Executions May Cause Paralysis, Pain for Conscious Inmates
Tuesday, April 24, 2007
The cocktail of drugs used for lethal injections is unreliable and could render inmates paralyzed but not unconscious, unable to cry out as they experience excruciating pain and eventually suffocate, according to a new scientific analysis.
The analysis, released yesterday and based on published data about the three drugs used and public records of executions in North Carolina and California, concluded that the protocol does not dependably induce a quick, painless death.
"This raises the possibility people are being tortured and you can't see it because they are paralyzed," said University of Miami surgery professor Leonidas G. Koniaris, who led the analysis. "I'm not sure a civilized society should be doing this."
The analysis comes at a time of turmoil over the use of lethal injection. At least 11 states have suspended executions after botched injections raised questions about the procedure and its administration.
The analysis, which was conducted to determine whether the process works when done correctly, concludes that the process is fundamentally flawed.
"I find it very disturbing," said Teresa A. Zimmers, a University of Miami research assistant professor who helped write the report.
"There is very little science behind this protocol, and the picture of lethal injection being a humane way to execute someone is completely wrong," she said.
The findings were seized upon by opponents of the death penalty.
"It's horrifying to read this," said Deborah W. Denno of Fordham University's law school. "What states are supposed to do is execute inmates in a humane way. There is clearly pain and suffering occurring."
But death-penalty supporters dismissed the findings as based on faulty assumptions.
"This doesn't pass the smell test," said Michael Rushford of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, a victims' rights group. "These people wouldn't be okay with Ethel Merman singing people to death."
Although the exact protocol for lethal injections varies from state to state, all use the same three drugs in large enough doses that any one alone should work. The first is sodium thiopental, a barbiturate intended to render the inmate unconscious at the start of the procedure and to prevent pain and suffering. The second drug, pancuronium bromide, paralyzes the muscles. The third drug, potassium chloride, is used to stop the heart.