Suspect in Kan. Teen's Death Had Record

In this handout photo provided by the Johnson County (Kan.) Sheriff's Office, released Thursday, June 7, 2007, Edwin Roy Hall is shown. Hall, 26, was charged Thursday with premeditated first-degree murder and aggravated kidnapping, according to the Johnson County Court Web site. Bond was set at $5 million. The body of Kelsey Smith, 18, who had been missing since Saturday night when she went to a Target store, was found Wednesday in a wooded area, authorities said. (AP Photo/Johnson County Sheriff) (AP)

TOPEKA, Kan. -- A man accused of kidnapping and killing a suburban Kansas City teenager pleaded no contest as a 15-year-old to threatening his sister at knifepoint, according to court records.

Edwin R. Hall remained jailed on $5 million bond Friday, a day after being charged with first-degree murder and aggravated kidnapping in 18-year-old Kelsey Smith's abduction from a Target parking lot.

Prosecutors said Friday that Smith was strangled with a ligature but would not say exactly what was used.

A judge ordered Hall removed from his home after he entered the plea to aggravated assault in May 1996, and he was placed in state custody, the court records state. A second charge of making a criminal threat was dismissed.

Hall's parents, Carol and Don Hall, of Emporia, didn't immediately return a call Friday. One of their daughters, Sheila Garza, answered the door at the parents' home and said the family would not comment except to say: "We are devastated for Kelsey's family and their loss."

Court records indicate Garza was not the daughter Edwin Hall threatened.

Carol Hall told The Emporia Gazette for Friday's editions that the couple adopted Edwin Hall when he was 7 and knew he had problems associated with his early childhood.

Court records show the boy ran afoul of police several times before the attack on his sister, who a biological child of the couple, though the earlier offenses were nonviolent.

In Kansas, court files are open for crimes involving defendants who are at least 14 years old, said Ron Keefover, spokesman for the state judicial system. A judge also can choose not to close records for defendants younger than 14.

Carol Hall told the paper the boy did something when he was 15 that made the couple feel he was a danger to the family, which included three biological daughters. She did not provide details but said the couple felt they would have to give up on him.

"That was the last time he was in our home," Carol Hall told the newspaper. The Halls hoped then that someone would be able "to get him the help that he needed," she said.

Hall was confined in four facilities from 1996 until 1999, according to the Kansas Juvenile Justice Authority.

In 2002, Hall and his adoptive parents were sued by a Lyon County man who claimed Hall beat him in the back of the head with a baseball bat, court records show. The man sought $50,000 from the family, but the case was dismissed.

Hall, 26, of Olathe, faces at least 25 years in prison if convicted of the murder charge and more than 12 years on the aggravated kidnapping count.

Johnson County District Attorney Phill Kline said it was unclear whether the case would be tried in state or federal court but that the death penalty would be possible either way.

Hall's attorney of record, Paul Cramm, declined to comment Friday through his secretary.