Va. Tech Victims' Families Weigh Suits Against State
Thursday, September 6, 2007
RICHMOND, Sept. 5 -- The relatives of seven of the slain victims of the Virginia Tech massacre have retained a Washington law firm that specializes in high-profile wrongful death cases, raising the prospect of an expensive legal battle between the state and the families over whether the university could have done more to prevent the shootings.
Peter Grenier and Douglas Fierberg, of Bode & Grenier, said the families are considering wrongful death suits and a federal civil rights claim against the state because they believe university officials could have done more to prevent the April 16 shootings by Seung Hui Cho.
"My view is it is absolutely clear from the panel report that there were a number of glaring omissions by Virginia Tech that resulted in the deaths of students," Fierberg said, referring to the findings of an investigation by a commission appointed by Gov. Timothy M. Kaine (D).
Under the Virginia Tort Claims Act, the relatives have until next April 16 to file a notice of possible legal action against the state. Grenier declined to discuss when such a claim might be filed, but said, "I certainly do think there are legal claims to be pursued."
Grenier and Fierberg's comments are the clearest signal yet that Virginia could face a protracted legal battle with the relatives of the Virginia Tech victims.
Attorney General Robert F. McDonnell (R), who would represent the state in any legal proceeding, declined to comment. Larry Hincker, Virginia Tech's associate vice president for university relations, also declined to comment.
The attorneys represent the families of students Mathew Gregory Gwaltney, 24, of Chesterfield, Va.; Caitlin Hammaren, 19, of Westtown, N.Y.; Juan Ramon Ortiz, 26, of, Puerto Rico; Reema Samaha, 18, of Centreville; Nicole R. White of Smithfield, Va.; Brian Bluhm, 25, of Detroit; and Michael Pohle, 23, of Flemington, N.J. Grenier and Fierberg said they were are finalizing agreements to represent three additional families.
Several of the families have kept a low profile and shunned the spotlight since the shootings. Their decision to retain counsel comes as state officials were taking steps to limit the number of relatives they potentially would have to meet in court. The families have the option to receive $180,000 from a private fund, separate from any potential lawsuits.
Grenier has won large settlements from state and local governments, even though many, including Virginia, are supposed to have immunity from such lawsuits. In 2001, Grenier won a $1.5 million settlement in a wrongful death case against Jefferson County, Colo., stemming from the Columbine High School shootings in 1999. He also won a record $98 million verdict against the District in 1999 in a case involving a drug informant who was killed when he was supposed to be under police protection.
Cho killed two people at Virginia Tech's West Ambler Johnston dormitory the morning of April 16. About 2 1/2 hours later, at the Norris Hall academic building, Cho shot and killed 30 students and faculty members before turning the gun on himself. An additional two dozen students and faculty members were injured.
Kaine's panel issued its final report last week, concluding that Cho's rampage was probably unavoidable because he was intent on killing people that day. But the panel also found that lives could have been saved had the university alerted students sooner about the shooting in the dormitory and canceled classes because the gunman had not been caught. Additionally, the report said that the university's counseling center was passive in its lack of treatment for Cho.
Current and former state officials say they fear the state could face dozens of lawsuits from injured students and the relatives of those killed by Cho.