7:30 p.m., Daily Grill, Bethesda
Sue: Rob wasn't at the restaurant when I arrived, so I went straight to the bar.
Rob: The hostess pointed Sue out. She was very attractive. Her fun personality was there from the beginning. We shook hands, and she said, "Bartender, he looks like he needs a drink!"
Sue: I was drinking a Tanqueray and tonic, which he also ordered. So it was karma, the alcohol compatibility. He's definitely in the general parameters of my type: dark hair, smiles a lot, good teeth, good clothes. He even had a little magnetism.
Rob: We ordered appetizers and sat at the bar chatting. Neither one of us is quiet or shy, so we bonded immediately. I found out that she lives across the street from me.
Sue: I can literally see his building from my window. I can't believe that we've never met. We had a ton of things in common. We're both Jewish, though he's not incredibly observant. We'd both gone to the University of Michigan -- we even lived in the same dorm, though he was a year after me. My roommate was in his comedy group.
Rob: We got a table, ordered dinner. By then, we'd gotten past the typical first-date questions. She's a former prosecutor, so there were a couple of times when she was giving me the third degree. She asked: "So, Rob, you're 40 years old, you're attractive, you seem great. Why aren't you married?"
Sue: I'm paying him a total compliment -- I [know] a hundred women who'd salivate to spend time with him. But, yes, I've been told that I ask a lot of questions. When he told me about his 40th birthday party in the Bahamas earlier this year -- a group of friends planned it for him -- I also told him I was 41.
Rob: I thought about her age only because having kids is very important to me. We'd have to get started real quick. It's not that I wouldn't consider [it, but] honestly, I'm expecting I'll end up with someone in their early-to-mid-30s.
Sue: If he wants to have two or three kids, he should probably be with somebody younger. But that is what it is.
Rob: Being a guy, I can't tell if there was a serious romantic spark. If I had to guess, I'd say it seemed like we were pals.
Sue: I don't believe that at all. We were flirty. At his suggestion, we went for ice cream at Gifford's, about five blocks away. On our walk there, he did the small-of-the-back touch thing. We shared a scoop of chocolate marshmallow. Then he gave me a ride to my place in his convertible. That was the best part of the date! I love convertibles. The only problem was the ride was only four blocks.
Rob: I gave her my business card, and there was a peck on the lips, yes. The mouths stayed closed, however. I'd call the date a 4 [out of 5]. She's a great girl.
Sue: As a blind date, this was a 4.5. He's a top-notch guy. The kid thing may not work in our favor, but I'd be very surprised if we didn't see each other again.
Interviews by Jill Hudson Neal
UPDATE: Sue and Rob met for drinks, hung out with friends, even played golf at Sue's country club. They both say they expect to maintain their friendship.
WANT DATE LAB TO SET YOU UP? Go to washingtonpost.com/datelab for details.