washingtonpost.com > Business > Local Business
Page 2 of 2   <      

Downside of Dominance?

F-16 fighter jets are assembled at Hangar 8, where the plane was first built in the 1970s, at a Lockheed Martin plant in Fort Worth.
F-16 fighter jets are assembled at Hangar 8, where the plane was first built in the 1970s, at a Lockheed Martin plant in Fort Worth. (By Courtney Perry For The Washington Post)
Discussion Policy
Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies or any other policies governing this site. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.

The F-35 would not be the only stealth fighter jet in the U.S. arsenal; the other is the F-22, also made by Lockheed.

The original developer of the F-16 was General Dynamics, which in 1993 sold its aeronautics business to Lockheed for $1.5 billion. At the time, some critics wondered why Lockheed would want the F-16 program, in particular because it was seen as a mature fighter jet without much gas left in its tank. In fact, shortly before Lockheed bought the program, there had been a slowdown in F-16 orders, and General Dynamics considered shutting down some of the production and laying off thousands of workers. But President George H. W. Bush, who was facing election-year pressure in Texas in 1992, lifted a ban on the sale of F-16s to Taiwan. The country bought 150.

"That's what ultimately saved the program," said Richard Aboulafia, a military analyst with the Teal Group.

Hundreds of international sales have followed. Turkey has 240, with plans for 30 more. Israel has more than 200. The Netherlands has 213. South Korea has 180. Greece has 140 and an order for 30 more. Lockheed officials said they foresee opportunities to sell several hundred more F-16s to foreign governments. India is reviewing proposals for 126 fighter jets, but the situation is complicated politically both there and with its rival Pakistan, which has ordered 18 F-16s. Morocco could buy some as well.

The company's aeronautics unit -- its largest revenue generator, projected to top $12 billion this year -- gets about 22 percent of its sales through international orders. Analysts expect more than $1.8 billion in revenue for F-16s in 2007. Lockheed has a backlog of 116 F-16 orders on its books, pushing production into 2012, but after that, it's anyone's guess.

"It has stuck around a long time," said Joseph Nadol, an analyst with J.P. Morgan. "It's still important and will be important for the next few years."

Military analysts said that U.S. allies are attracted to the plane for two primary reasons: because air campaigns can more easily be conducted as coalitions if allies own similar fighter jets, but more importantly, because Lockheed has been so adept at installing the latest war fighting technology on the frame of what is otherwise an older plane. Such upgrades have helped the F-16 generate remarkable survivability statistics in combat: With more than 200,000 sorties flown, the plane has been shot down just six times.

"This suggests that the plane in the majority of the world's air forces is still a very, very good plane," said O'Hanlon, the Brookings analyst. "I think it's the best fighter pound for pound, dollar for dollar."

Bill McHenry is in charge of selling them for Lockheed. As he puts it, "This is not your father's F-16." Asked why, he ticks off a slew of technological upgrades. The F-16 has gone from having minimal radar ability in the 1970s to having some of the latest air-to-air and air-to-ground radars. Countries such as Greece, which doesn't have in-air fuel tankers, have requested that extra gas tanks be fitted on top of the planes. Lockheed obliged. The F-16 now has helmet mounted cueing, which displays targeting information on the visor of the pilot's helmet.

"We like the F-16 for its operational capability versus the money," said Spyros Georgopoulos, the air attache to Greece and a former F-16 pilot. "You get outstanding agility and the capability to successfully convert from air-to-air to air-to-ground missions."

A diplomatic source with knowledge of how a recent sale was conducted in Greece said U.S. officials do not put pressure on foreign governments to buy U.S. products to maintain good relations. Rather, embassy officials played up the cost of the plane in comparison with its capabilities. "There was no political linkage," said the source, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because he wasn't authorized to speak about the sale. "Rather it was, 'This is a good deal, and this is the place to go.' " U.S. Embassy staff in Greece helped officials there negotiate the contract through a government program allowing Greece to pay about the same amount for the planes as the United States would.

Despite the continuing sales, there is concern from the Air Force -- and even some military analysts who support continuing production of the F-16 -- that the plane doesn't have the stealth capabilities needed for battles of the future.

Lockheed has been able to lower the plane's visibility on radar by coating its body with certain materials, though for security reasons, Lockheed officials declined to be more specific. Critics contend that long-range precision missiles limit the need to fly within range of radar and that many enemy air defense systems aren't sophisticated enough to do harm to the F-16. Also, there are ways for pilots to fly without tripping off air defense systems. For instance, Greek Air Force pilots flying in formation sometimes have all the planes except one turn off their radar, Georgopoulos said.

Their opponents counter this way: There is no telling what the future holds. The rise of China, Iran and other potential foes means the United States must have a more dominant fighter than the F-16.

"You have to assume with globalization that technology is spreading rapidly around the world," said Jacques Gansler, former undersecretary of defense for acquisition. "The F-35 is really a future system for when everyone will have sophisticated radars."

Thompson, the Lexington Institute analyst, said of the F-16: "In the future, that plane won't be survivable in Serbia much less China."


<       2


More in Local Business

Brian Krebs

Local Blog

Post's local business staff keep you informed on local business news.

Post 200

Special Report

Our annual guide to the top businesses in the Washington, D.C. area.

Metro News

More News

More information about business news in the Washington region.

© 2007 The Washington Post Company