THE BLACKFACE INCIDENT
Citing Agency Officials' Actions After Party, Panel Asks for Probes
Thursday, April 10, 2008
A House panel is calling for independent investigations of whether senior U.S. immigration enforcement officials violated federal laws after they honored a white agency employee dressed as an escaped black prisoner at an office Halloween party.
Julie L. Myers, head of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), last fall acknowledged ordering the destruction of photographs of the worker, who was given a "most original costume award" at an ICE charity event Oct. 31 by a three-judge panel that included Myers.
In a report released Tuesday, the House Homeland Security Committee, chaired by Rep. Bennie G. Thompson (D-Miss.), concluded that Myers also ordered the relocation of the worker from ICE headquarters in Washington.
The steps "appeared to be an attempt to conceal her actions from the public disclosure," which might have harmed Myers's chances for confirmation by the Senate, the committee said. Myers was approved in December.
Myers apologized to ICE workers in an e-mail Nov. 2. She said she learned only the day after the party that the man was wearing makeup, but acknowledged the costume could convey disrespect toward immigrants whom ICE detains. The agency runs a 32,000-bed detention system.
ICE spokeswoman Kelly Nantel said the worker was detailed to Washington on a short-term assignment, then placed on administrative leave and returned to his field office post "because it was felt he was not using good judgment in the costume he chose to wear."
Myers "communicated with ICE employees days before the incident was reported in the media or before there was a congressional inquiry, and to suggest there was some sort of a cover-up is completely without merit," Nantel said. "We operated with 100 percent transparency."
Laura Keehner, a spokeswoman for the Department of Homeland Security, of which ICE is a part, said that "we will review Chairman Thompson's recommendations, but note that the report is fundamentally flawed and highly partisan."
The worker, whom officials have declined to identify citing his "personal privacy," wore dreadlocks and dark makeup and described himself as a detainee from ICE's facility in Miami, the report said.
"I'm a Jamaican detainee from Krome -- obviously, I've escaped," he told the judges, who responded with laughter, the report stated.
Myers told lawmakers last fall that within minutes of leaving the party, she recognized that she had made "an error in judgment." She said she told her chief of staff to direct the event photographer to delete all photographs of the employee so they would not be inadvertently published. The images were recovered after a news organization filed a Freedom of Information Act request.
Thompson's report recommended that the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission investigate whether the costume award contributed to "a hostile work environment" at ICE; that the Office of Special Counsel examine whether ICE disciplinary actions broke federal personnel rules; and that an independent official determine whether ordering the destruction of photographs was illegal.
Nantel said it was not ICE's place to respond to those recommendations, but she noted that the agency cooperated fully with an internal Homeland Security Department review. She said that under Myers's leadership, the number of EEO complaints alleging retaliation fell from 105 in 2006 to 29 last year.
The House panel cited the Office of Personnel Management's Web site in reporting that, as of March 2007, none of ICE's 28 Senior Executive Service employees were African Americans. Nantel said the actual number was two, or 4 percent.
Myers has been supported by Homeland Security's National Association of African-Americans and the American Federation of Government Employees, Nantel said.