By Matt Zapotosky
Washington Post Staff Writer
Sunday, April 27, 2008
Jeannie Moreland remembers the night she barricaded herself in her room to escape an abusive boyfriend. She remembers him kicking the door with such force that it burst open, striking her in the forehead and leaving a scar that remains today, almost 13 years later.
Disoriented from the impact and a beating that preceded it, Moreland said, she heard her 16-month-old daughter crying in another room. When she came to, she said, her boyfriend was standing over her, the lifeless child in his arms.
"She was a perfectly healthy baby who all of a sudden was gone one night," Moreland said in an interview last week.
On Wednesday, in a Charles County courtroom, the former boyfriend, Theodore J. Seman Jr., is expected to be sentenced to as many as 15 years in prison in the death of the baby, Nina Leann McDonald. Last month, Seman, 35, pleaded guilty to a charge of second-degree murder under the Alford doctrine, meaning he did not admit responsibility but acknowledged that the state had enough evidence against him to secure a conviction, said David Simpson, his attorney.
The expected outcome is "bittersweet" for Moreland.
"Fifteen years for an entire life doesn't even begin to scratch the surface, especially when he walked around for 13 years as if she never existed," said Moreland, 35. "I still feel dragged down by the whole thing, because obviously it's never going to go away. It's something that I will never forget."
Investigators said they pegged Seman as a suspect in the Sept. 23, 1995, death from the start, even after an autopsy report concluded that Nina died under "suspicious circumstances" but did not rule her death a homicide. In 2001, that report was amended to indicate a homicide, with the cause of death "asphyxia."
Even so, Seman remained free until last year, when police charged him with first-degree murder and child abuse.
Kristen Timko, a spokeswoman for the county sheriff's office, said the case took a long time because police had to re-interview witnesses and have new medical experts review the evidence after the autopsy report was modified. There wasn't any one new piece of information that made charges possible, she said.
"With their expert analysis and conclusions in the witness statements, we were able to eventually piece together what happened," she said. "This one took a long time, but we weren't about to give up on it."
The detective in the case and State's Attorney Leonard C. Collins Jr. said they would not comment until after Seman is sentenced.
Seman's account, according to his statement to police, is that he and Moreland were sleeping when she woke him and asked him to check on the baby. He went into Nina's room and grabbed her feet as part of a game of "piggly wiggly." When he stopped, Seman told police, she took a deep breath and closed her eyes.
"When I went to pick her up, she was like a spaghetti noodle in my arms," Seman said, according to the statement. "Right away, I knew something wasn't right."
Seman was the last person with the child. Photographs of the baby showed bruises that the medical examiner would have testified were consistent with child abuse, Simpson said.
"Just the sympathy factor alone was something I think he had to take into account," Simpson said. "Even if you go to trial and win, you're still looking at a child-abuse count, and I'm not sure a jury was going to let this case go."
Moreland did not immediately blame Seman for Nina's death, even after police told her that he was a suspect. She stayed with him for a few months afterward -- mainly, she said, out of fear that he might hurt her if she left. Seman was abusive throughout their months-long relationship, she said.
"I was trying to give him the benefit of the doubt," she said. "He was there swearing to me on everything on the face of the Earth that he didn't do anything. I didn't really know who or what to believe."
She said, however, that she began to suspect that Seman was responsible for her daughter's death as time passed and he continued to act violently toward her. Months later, she said, she came to the conclusion that he had killed Nina.
Moreland now lives in La Plata, has two other children and co-owns a business with her current boyfriend. Whatever happens Wednesday will not restore normalcy to her life, she said.
"That day changed everything that I ever thought I knew about myself or this entire world," she said. "I don't think for one minute I'm the same person today that I would have been if she were still here."
View all comments that have been posted about this article.