Detention Deficit

Saturday, May 17, 2008

A 34-YEAR-OLD man being held in a U.S. facility for foreign detainees dies of heart failure after employees wait more than 40 minutes after his collapse to provide medical help. A permanent legal resident facing deportation because of a 10-year-old conviction for buying stolen jewelry is denied treatment for a suspected recurrence of cancer. An 81-year-old Baptist minister, seeking asylum from his native Haiti, perishes in custody after a nurse concludes he was faking illness.

Health problems misdiagnosed or ignored, detainees injected with psychotropic drugs to make them easier to transport, suicides that could have been prevented. These and other disturbing examples of neglect or incompetence were documented in a four-part series this week by Post reporters Dana Priest and Amy Goldstein that focused on the medical treatment received by the hundreds of thousands of foreigners who are shuffled through the immigration detention system every year. Some are held for legal violations that make them a target for deportation; some are seeking asylum and are being held until their cases are decided. All are in the custody of the U.S. government, which, after the 2001 terrorist attacks, abandoned its "catch and release" approach and opted for detention of all those who may be subject to deportation.

On any given day, there are roughly 33,000 detainees in custody. Over the past five years, since the creation of the Department of Homeland Security, hundreds of thousands of detainees have gone through the system. The Post series documented 83 detainee deaths during this time. Given the size of the population, a certain number of deaths is unavoidable, and the Division of Immigration Health Services (DIHS), the unit of Homeland Security that provides medical care for detainees, argues that these statistics show that it provides competent care for the vast majority of those being held. The agency notes that it is prohibited from commenting on specific cases because of the privacy rights of detainees. But even some who work for the DIHS have expressed serious concerns about its ability to provide adequate care to this growing population because of staff shortages and budget shortfalls that inevitably lead to neglect or errors.

The skyrocketing rate of these detentions is not accidental; it is a direct result of an administration policy decision. The administration should rethink this policy. Does it really make sense to hold someone such as Yong Sun Harvill, the woman with the suspected recurrence of cancer, when, if released, she would undoubtedly return to her Florida home to be with her husband and seek care? If the government determines that she must be deported, it's likely she would be easily found.

Funding for the beleaguered system also must be increased. Human error cannot always be avoided, but continuing to underfund and understaff the medical care system for these detainees only increases the chances of an unnecessary tragedy. The law requires that those in U.S. custody be given adequate treatment. Simple decency demands no less.

© 2008 The Washington Post Company