By Maureen Fan
Washington Post Foreign Service
Sunday, May 18, 2008
BEIJING -- "Are we going to continue to cover the earthquake?" the Guangzhou-based reporter asked in an instant message to his editor, a day after China's deadliest earthquake in three decades struck Sichuan province.
"Of course," replied the editor, surnamed Yang. "Why not?"
Then, the reporter said, he forwarded to his boss the text of the latest edict from the propaganda department of the Communist Party Central Committee, ordering domestic news media not to send any more journalists to Sichuan.
Yang wrote back, "If everyone pays no attention to this, then it won't really be a ban."
The questioning of the party directive was largely consistent with how China's normally timid news media have reacted to Monday's massive earthquake. Journalists have covered the disaster with unprecedented openness and intensity, broadcasting nearly nonstop live television footage, quickly updating death tolls on the Internet and printing bold newspaper editorials calling for building industry and other reforms.
In 1976, after an earthquake razed Tangshan in the northeastern province of Hebei, the death toll of 240,000 was treated as a state secret for years. When snowstorms crippled southern China during this year's Spring Festival, much local news coverage was late and lacking in detail.
This week's expansive coverage of the disaster, however, has mobilized a tearful public to donate blood, money and labor, while also giving the nation a good look at the scope of the problem, from scores of collapsed schools to a desperate need for doctors. The coverage has also encouraged citizens to raise questions about the rescue effort, worrying government officials who prefer to control the narrative themselves.
"We know the directives from the propaganda department exist, but if the leadership finds that greater openness serves their interests, maybe they'll reconsider how they handle these things generally," said David Bandurski, a researcher with the China Media Project at Hong Kong University. "If we talk about the media being on a leash, it's still true, but the leash has been lengthened."
China's media are entirely state-controlled, but since the economic reforms of the 1990s, the commercialization of the industry has meant racier content and more aggressive headlines as news organizations compete for readers, viewers and advertising dollars. Skyrocketing use of the Internet has also eroded the efficiency of national censors.
On Monday, after the quake struck at 2:28 p.m., the news page of the popular Sina.com Web site reported within minutes that office buildings were shaking in Hunan province. At 2:46 p.m., the Web site of the official New China News Agency reported that tremors had been felt in the suburbs of Beijing, 10 minutes after vibrations from the quake were registered in the capital. By 2:53 p.m., less than half an hour after the quake rocked Sichuan province, an online New China News Agency report had named Wenchuan county as the epicenter.
Shortly after that, CCTV began to broadcast live. Web sites immediately devoted special sections to the story. The public traded information online, through instant messaging, bulletin boards and blogs.
"The transparency of information can unite everybody to fight against the big tragedy," said Min Dahong, a journalism professor at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. "This is a good opportunity to establish a system that will encourage the press to report in a timely and open manner. I think the government learned a lesson from the snowstorm coverage."
Chinese are now asking what they can do besides donate and what more can be done by the government, said Russell Leigh Moses, an analyst of Chinese politics who is based in Beijing. "There's an anxiety in the Chinese government that the agenda and the story is not being shaped by them."
On Friday, CCTV showed President Hu Jintao taking control of the rescue effort -- in flight, poring over a map of the quake area; consoling victims in a medical tent; and with a bullhorn, addressing rescuers. "Right now, the fight against the disaster has reached the most critical moment. We must fight for victory against the disaster," Hu said, his words echoed in a logo displayed on the lower right corner of the CCTV screen, "Fight the quake, rescue the disaster."
In contrast with official state media such as the People's Daily newspaper, commercial publications have had a freer hand covering the disaster.
The Web site of the Beijing-based financial magazine Caijing carried an editorial Thursday by Huang Fuping, a former deputy editor in chief of the People's Daily, challenging officials' decision to continue the Olympic torch relay in the wake of the recent tragedy.
"Right now the Olympic torch relay is in Jiangxi province, and there still are 27 provinces to go and thousands of torchbearers waiting," Huang wrote. "Under these circumstances, the strategy of the torch relay of the Beijing Olympic Games should be adjusted. It should be suspended between the provinces. After decisive progress has been made in the rescue effort, then we should pass the torch directly from the affected areas of the quake to Beijing."
The same day, the Shanghai Securities News demanded the construction of buildings better able to withstand earthquakes and an end to the corruption that has resulted in shoddily built schools. "If buildings were constructed strictly according to proper standards, most of the buildings should survive an earthquake like the one in Wenchuan, and the casualties wouldn't be so numerous," the paper said in an editorial, noting that 95 percent of earthquake casualties are caused by the collapse of buildings.
In a particularly dramatic piece of coverage, Chinese TV viewers earlier this week watched as a CCTV news anchor, Zhao Pu, struggled to compose himself as he reported on the earthquake. He was widely praised for showing emotion, unlike many of the staid, rigid anchors on state-controlled TV.
"Zhao's tears make the cold face of CCTV warm," said an anonymous poster on Tianya, a popular Chinese Internet forum.
Researcher Liu Songjie contributed to this report.
View all comments that have been posted about this article.