Yahoo Cedes Three Board Spots to Icahn, Ending Proxy Fight
Tuesday, July 22, 2008
A duel for control of Internet giant Yahoo ended yesterday with company officials and billionaire investor Carl C. Icahn announcing that they had reached an accord.
Icahn comes away earning a seat for himself and two others on a newly enlarged, 11-member Yahoo board.
Yahoo leaders, meanwhile, have blocked Icahn from gaining an even larger share of board seats at the company's annual shareholder meeting on Aug. 1.
"Everyone is able to save face," and by avoiding a bitter showdown, the pact makes sense for shareholders, said Chris Young, director of mergers and acquisitions research at RiskMetrics Group. But because neither side can claim victory, "neither will feel terrific."
Namely, Yahoo chief executive Jerry Yang and Chairman Roy Bostock have been forced to give board seats to the sometimes brash Icahn, who conducted a dissident campaign in which he belittled their business decisions.
And Icahn, who had accumulated a 5 percent stake in Yahoo, has been forced to give up his attempt to take control of the Yahoo board and force a sale of the company to Microsoft. While Microsoft had earlier this year sought to acquire Yahoo, it no longer seems interested.
"Icahn is obviously not in the position he wanted to be in," Young said. "He won't be able to force a sale to Microsoft. I don't know that he will feel that he has won."
The battle over Yahoo, one of the world's most popular Web companies, has been closely watched not only for the deal's proportions but because it is coveted by those who think nearly all media will be delivered via the Internet in the future. If so, a Web company whose sites get as many as 140 million visitors a month may be well-positioned to profit.
Yahoo's second-quarter earnings are due today.
Microsoft, which has fallen behind in Web services, sought to catch up in the Internet arena by trying to acquire Yahoo for $44.6 billion.
When Yahoo officials rebuffed Microsoft, some Yahoo shareholders expressed frustration, arguing that the offer had been too generous to pass up.
Out of that discontent sprang Icahn, who accumulated a stake in Yahoo and nominated an alternate slate of directors.