Working to Save Innocent Souls

The Rev. Jim McCloskey is the founder of Centurion Ministries, which has brought freedom to 43 inmates since its first case in 1983.
The Rev. Jim McCloskey is the founder of Centurion Ministries, which has brought freedom to 43 inmates since its first case in 1983. (Robert Sciarrino - Star-Ledger)
By Sarah Golin
Religion News Service
Saturday, October 25, 2008

PRINCETON, N.J. -- Two months ago, Daryl Burton was sitting in a jail cell in Jefferson City, Mo., serving the 24th year of his sentence in the shooting death of a gas station attendant.

On a recent Saturday, Burton stood in a leafy back yard under a white tent with about 125 other partygoers. "This seems surreal. I'm still pinching myself," Burton, 46, said. "This is unbelievable."

Burton had been sentenced to 75 years in prison for the 1984 slaying, a crime he said he didn't commit. He was freed Aug. 29 after an eight-year legal effort by the Rev. Jim McCloskey and McCloskey's co-workers at the Princeton-based Centurion Ministries.

McCloskey has been laboring nearly 30 years to exonerate innocent prisoners and hosted a gathering to celebrate the release of seven imprisoned men in the past two years.

"Each of these seven men spent anywhere from 24 to 30 years in prison for the crimes of other people. Collectively, they spent 188 years in prison," McCloskey told the crowd, which included the men and their families, lawyers and investigators who worked on the cases; other exonerated inmates; and well-to-do Princeton supporters of Centurion.

In the Missouri case, Centurion investigators uncovered key witnesses who had never been presented to the defense.

Going to prison will change anyone, Burton said, "but when you are in prison for a crime you didn't commit, that just compounds the issue. . . . You have to face physical, mental and emotional trauma, and you never know what's going to happen day-to-day. . . . And you haven't done anything to be there."

The fight to clear a convicted inmate is long, expensive and full of uncertainty. "Once you are convicted, all odds are stacked against you," said Barry Scheck, a New York lawyer and founder of the Innocence Project, which exonerates inmates primarily through the use of DNA evidence. "To get a conviction vacated is extremely difficult."

Centurion has brought freedom to 43 inmates since its first case in 1983, poring over documents, re-interviewing witnesses and running down people the police never talked to.

"We're like the tortoise," said Kate Germond, who met McCloskey in 1986 after reading an article about him in the New York Times. She became Centurion's second paid staff member and is now its co-director.

Germond, 61, says it might take Centurion five years of investigating to decide whether to take a case. If the case is accepted, it typically takes another five years before the person has a shot at freedom.

Careful vetting, she says, is how the group determines a person is truly innocent, because instincts are often wrong. "Sometimes, the nicest guys turn out to be guilty, and the jerkiest guys turn out to be innocent," she said.

Costs for a case run from $150,000 to $300,000, according to McCloskey. Overall, the organization has an annual budget of about $1 million, mostly from private donors.

McCloskey, 66, came to his cause in midlife. Born into a well-to-do Philadelphia family, he graduated from Bucknell University and had a successful business career.

Yet despite financial success, "I felt shallow, selfish, unfulfilled, lacking any real authenticity in my life," he said. "I was single, I didn't have a family, and something was really missing."

He had stopped attending church in college but started worshiping again at a Presbyterian church outside Philadelphia. Over time, he started to feel a calling to enter the ministry.

"I'm reading the Scriptures on a Saturday night at home, and I just happened upon the 21st Chapter of Luke, where the resurrected Christ is talking to Peter and he says, 'When you were young, you walked where you would. When you are older, I will gird you and lead you to another place.' And so I thought the Scriptures were talking to me."

That other place would turn out to be Princeton Theological Seminary; from there, he went to a prison ministry that led to his current work.

He entered the seminary in fall 1979, and in his second year chose an internship as a student chaplain at New Jersey State Prison in Trenton, where he would counsel 40 men on a single tier. One was Jorge "Chiefy" de los Santos.

"From day one, all de Los Santos would talk about was his innocence. He would exhaust me, he was so obsessed," McCloskey said. "All he could talk about was how he got framed."

Unsure whether to believe him, McCloskey read through the trial transcripts.

"Around Christmastime, I came back to Chiefy and said: 'I believe you are innocent. Of course, I don't know if you're innocent, but I believe you, and I'm going to take a year off to move the ball forward, to see what I can do. That's my Christmas gift to you.'

"But it was also his gift to me. Because I thought, if this man is innocent, and I believe he is, and if I can help free him, that is a meaningful, purposeful endeavor, and this makes me feel as if I'm really doing something for someone else."

© 2008 The Washington Post Company