Officials Want Probe Of Lead-Study Paper
Saturday, February 14, 2009
Two D.C. Council members want the city's inspector general to probe the validity of a 2007 research paper that concluded that public health was not harmed several years ago by high concentrations of lead in drinking water.
The paper's author, Tee Guidotti, was a paid consultant for the D.C. Water and Sewer Authority and had a contract stating that the utility had final approval on anything published about it.
Editors of the National Institutes of Health journal that published the paper say they were unaware of the contract's stipulations. They also say Guidotti failed to change a critical sentence in the paper, as he was told, that read: "There appears to have been no identifiable public health impact from the elevation of lead in drinking water." Experts who reviewed the paper before publication rejected the finding.
Council members Mary M. Cheh (D-Ward 3) and Jim Graham (D-Ward 1), who held a joint public hearing on water quality this week, expressed outrage at the latest twist in an almost eight-year ordeal that began in 2001 when dangerous concentrations of lead were found to be leaking into drinking water.
Yesterday, The Washington Post published an article revealing the mistaken conclusion and potential conflicts in the research, which editors at the NIH journal are considering retracting.
The paper's assurance that drinking water was safe "was used over and over and over again," Graham said. "Now, to find out that such was not the case really calls into question the safety of the drinking water. . . . We're going to get to the bottom of this."
"There ought to be consequences," Cheh said. "If people are responsible for this . . . they ought to resign."
The two council members had already asked the inspector general to investigate whether WASA and public health agencies "negligently or intentionally" misled the public during the crisis.
Their Jan. 27 request followed a Post article on a study that found a correlation between elevated blood-lead levels in children and neighborhoods that had high lead levels in drinking water during the city's water crisis. Hundreds of D.C. children had harmful levels of lead in their blood, and thousands more may have been exposed to the danger, according to the study.
Attorney General Peter Nickles said the lead case continues to be an unraveling "mystery" and that he agrees with the call for further investigation.
"I certainly support an independent study by competent people," he said.
But Nickles warned against panic because officials have found the drinking water to be safe, although precautions, such as filters, are advised for infants, seniors and those with weak immune systems. Water treatment now minimizes the corrosion of lead service pipes.