A Left of Center-Right Country

By E.J. Dionne Jr.
Thursday, March 12, 2009

Maybe pragmatism isn't enough after all.

President Obama regularly speaks disdainfully of "ideology," says he is focused only on "what works" and loves to be described as "pragmatic."

Well, sure. No one ever admits to being an ideologue, and as historian Arthur Schlesinger Jr. observed many years ago, democratic government should be about "the search for remedy."

But there comes a time when first principles need to be articulated. The economic crisis has let loose a furious philosophical debate over the meltdown, its causes and its cures. Conservatives have entered this fight with guns blazing while Democrats, including at times the president, often want to retreat behind a Maginot Line armed only with the word "pragmatism."

It's true of course that Obama has answered many of the conservative arguments, particularly in his address to Congress last month. But he never wants to acknowledge that in doing so he is actually joining the ideological debate, and he always goes out of his way -- as in his repeated insistence that he never intended to increase the size of government -- to dull the philosophical edges.

He did win the election, so it's hard to quibble with his politcal effectivenes. But this is also surprising.

Deregulating the financial markets, we were told, would do wonders for growth, as would slashing the income taxes of the wealthy and levies on capital gains and dividends. We were urged to trust the Wall Street wizards creating those innovative financial instruments and to believe that jacking up CEO pay relative to everyone else's would be splendid for corporate performance. Don't worry, we were assured, about rising inequalities.

And it has all come crashing down.

Conservatives know that if the narrative I just offered takes hold, they and their ideas will be forced into the wilderness for a generation or more. So they are shrewdly changing the story line, trying to pretend that the past eight or even the past 30 years don't matter. They are trying to blame everything on Obama policies that have been operational for just a few weeks. And they are playing for keeps.

They are right to do so, because ideologically, the country is now on a knife-edge. The conventional view, pushed hard by conservatives, is that we are a "center-right" nation because polls tend to show that there are roughly three conservatives for every two liberals, with the rest of the country in the middle.

But a report released yesterday by the Center for American Progress suggests a more complicated and interesting picture. Rather than rely on the three-way liberal/moderate/conservative ideological matrix, the center offered poll respondents five choices: the old three, plus "progressive" and "libertarian."

The result: 36 percent of Americans say they are conservative or libertarian -- all but 2 percent of these are conservatives -- while 31 percent are liberal or progressive, split roughly evenly between the two groups. Moderates (and a small number who picked some other label) accounted for 31 percent.

CONTINUED     1        >

© 2009 The Washington Post Company