Judge in Stevens Dismissal Known for Tenacity
Friday, April 10, 2009
U.S. District Judge Emmet G. Sullivan was irate when he accused the Justice Department of "hiding the ball" after its lawyers did not produce a document that undercut a key witness.
"Unfortunately, I can't trust the government," he said, adding that "someone's going to pay a price."
It was the first of two tirades in a week that the judge let loose on government lawyers over their handling of evidence. First, he rebuked them in a case challenging the detention of a man at the U.S. military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. The second scolding came during a packed hearing Tuesday, before he dismissed the conviction of former senator Ted Stevens (R-Alaska) on corruption charges.
The harangues captured the vintage Sullivan, who has spent more than 20 years on the bench, recently presiding over a series of high-profile cases and building a reputation as a formidable, if unpredictable, presence in the courtroom.
Colleagues say the judge's repeated criticism of prosecutors in the Stevens case laid the foundation for the dismissal, a stunning end to one of Washington's most closely watched political trials. Without Sullivan hounding the Justice Department, they say, a new group of prosecutors may never have been assigned to the case. That team unearthed notes that contradicted testimony of a key government witness, leading to the department's request that Sullivan toss out the conviction and indictment.
At the federal courthouse, and lately in government and political circles, the judge has become a well-known figure. He blocked snowmobiles in national parks, is overseeing the sentencing of three people who pleaded guilty in a D.C. tax scam and handled a lengthy trial brought by animal rights activists who alleged that circus elephants were being mistreated.
In the case of the detainee, Sullivan's tirade strayed from the document into broader territory, when he called Guantanamo Bay a "travesty" and "horror story" that "ranks up there with the internment of Japanese American citizens years ago."
He threatened to bring U.S. diplomats into court for updates on their efforts to find the detainee a new home, then ordered the government to provide the document to every judge presiding over any detainee case.
In some quarters, Sullivan is considered a hero for holding government lawyers accountable. But his outspoken nature has brought him notice, even if he usually reins himself in. Often that comes after a consultation with his law clerk, Addy Schmitt, who during hearings regularly passes the judge notes about legal issues and other court matters.
During a critical phase of the Stevens trial, the judge grew upset that prosecutors presented faulty business records to the jury. He said he was going to tell jurors that prosecutors had introduced evidence that they "knew was not true," an instruction that could undercut their credibility. The next day, however, Sullivan was more restrained, telling the jury to ignore the documents without calling attention to prosecutors' motives.
"His rulings were all reasonable," said Chief U.S. District Judge Royce C. Lamberth. "He does wear his heart on his sleeve sometimes, but so do I. . . . It's probably not the first quality that comes to mind when you think of a judge."
Last year, Sullivan grew so agitated during the plea hearing of a 61-year-old man accused of pocketing nearly $1.6 million in the massive D.C. tax scam that the judge ordered him to jail before his sentencing, something even prosecutors had not requested.