Mainstream Physicians Try Such Alternatives as Herbs, Acupuncture and Yoga
Tuesday, June 9, 2009
A patient who comes to Marie Steinmetz with clogged sinuses might be in for a surprise.
Instead of walking out of the Alexandria family physician's office with a prescription, he might find himself stretched out in a dim room on a massage table. With soft music playing in the background, Steinmetz might quickly -- and gently -- stick several needles into his head and hands to help clear his nasal passages. For a chronic sufferer, she might suggest the use of a neti pot, an ayurvedic treatment popular in India and parts of Southeast Asia that involves flushing out the nasal passages with a water-based solution.
After more than a decade of treating patients with conventional medicine, Steinmetz, a board-certified family physician, has embraced an approach that combines Western medicine with complementary and alternative treatments that have roots in Eastern, Native American and European cultures and that have been used for hundreds, even thousands of years.
Make no mistake: Steinmetz will still hand out a penicillin prescription to fight an infection, but she also looks to Eastern and Native American traditions for clues to how to treat her patients' ailments. For an upset stomach, it might be an herbal remedy; for menstrual cramps, a bit of cramp bark.
"It's about treating the whole patient in the best way,'' she said.
Steinmetz is among a growing number of traditionally trained physicians who practice "integrative medicine": conventional medical care that incorporates strategies such as acupuncture, reiki and herbal remedies.
It's not just family practitioners who are taking this approach. Reed Shnider is an Olney-based preventive cardiologist who works with patients to prevent heart disease and who, depending on the patient, encourages them to take up yoga or tai chi to ease stress after bypass surgery. Iona Razi, a board-certified pediatrician in the District, is also a homeopath; i.e., she treats illness with small doses of remedies that are thought to activate the body's "self-healing response." John Pan, a clinical professor in the department of obstetrics and gynecology at the George Washington University Medical Center, incorporates Eastern medicine into his practice. He is also the founder of the Center for Integrative Medicine at the medical center.
The shift in attitudes toward alternative and complementary medicine was very clear to Xiao Ming Tian, director of the Academy of Acupuncture and Chinese Medicine at the Wildwood Acupuncture Center in Bethesda. In the early 1990s, he received few inquires from local physicians seeking his services. Today, he said, he gets hundreds of referrals a year.
Studies also show that the number of Americans willing to try alternative treatments continues to increase. A 2007 survey by the federal government found that more than one-third of adults and nearly 12 percent of children in the United States used alternative therapies, including acupuncture and herbal supplements.
Many mainstream physicians continue to be skeptical of alternative therapies, saying their efficacy has not been proven and their successes may be nothing more than variations of the placebo effect. But increasing numbers of institutions, including Johns Hopkins Hospital and the R Adams Cowley Shock Trauma Center at the University of Maryland Medical Center, have established integrative medicine units that bring together conventional and alternative approaches to care.
Health insurers are also beginning to recognize and pay for some alternative therapies, including acupuncture and herbal remedies, although Medicaid and Medicare do not cover them.
"It's not as evidence-based, which is why doctors are somewhat averse to the practice,'' said Shnider, who is affiliated with Cardiology Associates. "But if [they] didn't work, why would we still be doing them thousands of years later?"