Barbour's Efforts to Revive GOP May Also Boost Himself

By Dan Balz
Washington Post Staff Writer
Sunday, July 19, 2009

BILOXI, Miss., July 18 -- Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour was Republican National Committee chairman the last time his party was at such a low, after the election of 1992. Two years later, Republicans captured control of Congress, and although Newt Gingrich, who became the new House speaker, got much of the credit, party insiders say Barbour played a major role.

Sixteen years later, Republicans are looking to Barbour to help lead them back once more. It is perhaps ironic that, at a time of generational change in politics, an elder statesman such as Barbour, 61, is once again poised to play a pivotal role for his party, this time in the elections of 2009 and 2010. And although he says a presidential candidacy in 2012 is not likely, Barbour has refused to shut the door on speculation that he is interested.

This weekend, he is playing host to a meeting of the National Governors Association, a gathering of bipartisanship and bonhomie that is allowing him to show off how the Mississippi Gulf Coast has recovered under his leadership since Hurricane Katrina struck in August 2005. Once the meeting ends, he will turn back to partisan politics in his new assignment as chairman of the Republican Governors Association.

He is prospering as other GOP luminaries, including South Carolina Gov. Mark Sanford and Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, have stumbled.

He took over the chairmanship when Sanford resigned the post after admitting to an extramarital affair. Barbour has refrained from commenting on Sanford's problems and, in an interview on the eve of the NGA meeting, ducked the question of whether Palin's decision to resign is a responsible action by an incumbent governor.

"I am not smart enough to know whether this helps her or hurts her for 2012, or whether that's what it was focused on. I'm just ignorant of it." He paused and laughed, saying: "That's the best you're getting."

Over the next two years, Barbour will oversee the party's efforts in more than three dozen gubernatorial races, beginning this fall with attempts to capture Democratic-held governorships in Virginia and New Jersey. The 2009 and 2010 races will provide a clear indicator of whether the GOP is coming back.

Barbour knows all the reasons for the party's plight, but he argues that Republicans are not as bad off as the worst assessments suggest. Inside the party, his analysis and prescriptions are likely to be widely followed.

He worries that some Republicans see ideological purity as the route back, and argues that, if anything, the GOP must become more inclusive, not less.

"When you lose, there are some people who say, 'Well, now's the time to get pure,' " he said. "Well, purity in politics is about losing. Politics is about addition and multiplication; purity is about subtraction and division. . . . You have to remember that now is the time to have the most open of doors."

Barbour brings a number of potential liabilities to any role as the face of the party. His Southern drawl reinforces the image of a party that has become, in the estimation of many analysts, too Southern-based. He is hardly a fresh face for a repackaged GOP, having been in the thick of national politics for nearly three decades, including a stint as Ronald Reagan's White House political director. He was also one of Washington's most prominent and successful lobbyists, the very kind of people Barack Obama railed against last year.

But his assets make him especially attractive to fellow Republicans. He is an aggressive and effective partisan advocate who knows how to mix humor with political attack. He has a vast network and is respected by many Democratic adversaries. He is as comfortable talking about the details of the House energy bill as he is about the metrics of an effective political campaign.

And to his long résumé as a Washington insider, he adds two terms as a governor and praise for his handling of Katrina's aftermath. Other Republicans look to him for advice, guidance and leadership.

"If you're trying to demonstrate the importance of something on the Republican side, having Haley's name in the mix goes a long way," said Ed Gillespie, a former party chairman and Barbour's friend.

In an age of instant analysis, Barbour takes the long view concerning his party. Nothing is ever as bad or good as it appears in politics, he likes to say. He urges Republicans and their critics to take that advice as they evaluate the state of the GOP.

He acknowledges that Republicans have done little to help themselves in the six months Obama has been in office. But he believes, as do others in the party, that Obama's ambitious policies are providing an opening for the GOP to come back.

In recent weeks, Republicans have become more aggressive in seeking to portray Obama as an advocate of economic, health-care and energy policies that will give government too much power, explode the deficit and hurt business. Barbour articulates the case with an especially sharp edge, and said Obama is "far to the left of anybody else who's been elected president [or] who's ever run for president on a major-party ticket." He said Obama's policies are running up spending "that a year ago was just unthinkable."

White House senior adviser David Axelrod called Barbour's comments hyperbole, manufactured for Republican consumption. "Sounds like a guy who's running for the Republican nomination for president," Axelrod said.

For Barbour, thoughts of 2012 are on hold. But the RGA chairmanship affords him the opportunity to travel the country and gauge firsthand whether he should run. Four years ago, he assembled a kitchen cabinet of advisers to help keep his options open for a possible 2008 run, but Katrina swept away any thought of presidential politics. Will 2012 be different?

"At the end of 2010, I'll have a reasonable assessment of the mood of the country, of what ought to be and what ought not to be done," he said. "Any Republican who's not focused on [2009 and 2010] doesn't have his eye on the ball. I've given thousands of people that advice, and I've taken my own advice."

Barbour has long been one of the GOP's shrewdest strategists. "He knows when to strike, how to strike," said Don Fierce, who was part of Barbour's RNC team in the early 1990s. "With all the turmoil going on with others, he's been solid."

Barbour said he is "not Pollyannaish" about a quick comeback, noting that Obama is a formidable opponent. "He has all the charm that [Bill] Clinton does, plus he has the advantage of being an African American," Barbour said.

Elaborating, he said: "I think that most Americans are proud of the fact that America elected an African American president, that out of our past was slavery and the civil rights movement, and this makes a very positive statement about America."

He said he also has high regard for Obama's political team. "They're tough as nails," he said. "This the first White House since [Richard] Nixon that K Street is afraid of."

Although there are signs of trouble for Obama as he defends his stimulus package and fights to enact health-care reform and a big energy bill, most polls show he enjoys much greater public confidence than Republicans. Even so, Barbour says critiques of his party should not all be accepted as gospel.

Though Democrats have denounced the GOP as "the party of no," Barbour said that Republicans have their own ideas and that, in any case, opposition to Democratic initiatives will serve his party well. "It reminds me of the 2006 election, when the Democrats' campaign theme, and only theme, was, 'We ain't the Republicans.' "

To the question of why the party seems leaderless, he said: "There shouldn't be just one spokesman. When you're out, you're supposed to be bottom-up."

Barbour argued that many Americans, particularly independents who may have voted for Obama, are beginning to have second thoughts about the president.

Axelrod countered that Republicans remain tied to ideas from the past, and he rejected the notion that Obama has lost ground with voters. "In the data I've seen, the president is still very strong among independent voters," he said, "and I don't think the Republican Party is."

Some Republican strategists have warned of long-term problems for the GOP because of the country's demographic changes, particularly the growing Latino population, which went heavily for Obama. Barbour dismisses such concerns. "With the exception of African Americans, demographic groups move around a lot in their voting behavior," he said.

Whatever problems his party faces, Barbour argued that Obama is creating problems of his own that will become the focal point of a political debate that could help Republicans win elections over the next 18 months.

"I'm more optimistic than I was six months ago," he said. "I think the movement's been in our direction. We still have to have further movement, but the movement's been in our direction."

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

© 2009 The Washington Post Company