Swimsuits Cause More Questions Than Answers at World Championships
Monday, August 3, 2009
ROME, Aug. 2 -- When it was all over, when the last of the 43 world records had fallen at the Foro Italico during the eight-day swimming world championships, it was remarkable how little anybody actually learned. As swimmers in glossy polyurethane bodysuits obliterated virtually all of the sport's records, times became meaningless, and achievements hazy and unclassifiable.
This "will be remembered," USA Swimming National Team Director Mark Schubert said, "as the plastic meet."
Consider Sunday's results. As Michael Phelps collected his fifth gold medal and third world record here with the U.S. 4x100-meter individual medley relay team victory in 3 minutes 27.28 seconds, it wasn't merely the U.S. squad that went under the previous world record.
The second-place Germans, third-place Australians and fourth-place Brazilians did, too
The meet obliterated the previous record of 29 world bests set at the 1976 Olympics in Montreal, now known for the dominance of the steroid-enhanced East German swimmers. The long-length swimsuits that emerged as textile novelties in 2000 became high-tech weapons over the past 18 months and stole the headlines here.
"It is a game this year, and you're forced to play it," said American Christine Magnuson, who swam in four events but did not win any of the U.S. team's 22 medals overall, its lowest total since it won 20 in 1994. "It's kind of sad. Overall, I don't think the athletes are very happy right now."
More than 170 world records have been broken since the start of 2008, when the launch of Speedo's LZR set off the technological arms race. The suits, however, will never be seen at a major championship again. In response to the outcry over the most recent suits' obvious performance-enhancement, FINA, the sport's world governing body, announced it will ban long-length, non-textile suits next year.
But what happens to the swimmers who emerged here as stars is another matter entirely. Will they, too, disappear?
Did Germany's Paul Biedermann, who in the words of Phelps "destroyed" Phelps in the 200 freestyle while setting his second world record in three days, establish himself as one of the world's best swimmers? Or was it the suit? How about American Ariana Kukors, who set two world records in the 200 medley, an event in which she finished third at the U.S. championships three weeks prior?
And what to make of American Mary DeScenza, a working-class swimmer who failed to make the U.S. Olympic team last year, but set a world record in the morning heats of the 200 butterfly?
What does any of it mean?
"I don't think anyone really knows," said Sean Hutchison, the U.S. women's team coach who grew up in Columbia and attended Centennial High. "Only time will tell who is going to survive without the suits. . . . Some people who are the best in the world may just fall off and never be heard from again.