Researchers Explore Mental Health Benefits of Video Games
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
Gail Nichols has suffered from depression for years. When the 49-year-old resident of St. Marys, Kan., cannot sleep, she falls back on a form of entertainment that is gaining increasing credibility as a medical intervention: video games.
Nichols said she discovered the mental health benefits of video games some years ago during a particularly bad spell of depression. She had just started playing a game called Bejeweled, which requires players to move gems into rows based on their color. When she could not get to sleep one night and was tormented by mental pain, she said, she turned on the computer and played the game for hours.
"In the day, you can find someone to talk to," Nichols said. "Games are a big help in getting through to the next morning."
Nichols liked the game so much that she got in touch with the manufacturer, PopCap Games. The inventors of the game were surprised to hear about its possible mental health benefits, and the company decided to study Bejeweled's untapped potential systematically. In a preliminary study that PopCap commissioned and funded, researchers found that volunteers who played Bejeweled displayed improved mood and heart rhythms compared with volunteers who weren't playing. The preliminary study was published this year in the Annual Review of Cybertherapy and Telemedicine. Now, the company is about to launch a second phase of testing to see if the video games can have measurable effects on clinical markers of depression.
The research is part of a broad array of unconventional efforts that video game companies are devising to find new markets for their products. Many of these steps are based on the idea that depression and other disorders -- as well as everyday stress and worry -- involve systematic patterns of thought and self-doubt, and that games can distract people and put them in a different mental zone. You don't have to play with a computer or an Xbox 360 to notice the effect: Anyone who has used a crossword puzzle or Sudoku game to decompress after a difficult day recognizes the idea.
Nichols said she liked a version of the game where she was not competing against anyone or trying to rack up mammoth points. In her favorite version, colored gems drop endlessly onto the screen, and Nichols said she falls into a trance of simultaneous concentration and relaxation that she calls Zen.
Carmen Russoniello, who directs the psychophysiology lab and biofeedback clinic at East Carolina University in Greenville, N.C., is conducting the controlled research studies for PopCap. He said he has found the same pattern among many volunteers: Certain games allow people to fall into a rhythm where they can play without either effort or boredom. Russoniello said some games seem to activate the parasympathetic nervous system, which can reduce the heightened tension that is a natural response to stress.
The researcher hypothesized that one reason for the apparent mental health benefits of video games is that many people in Western countries find it impossible to switch off; they are always alert and stressed out. When those Type A people try to relax, they get bored because they have come to require a certain level of stressful arousal. Playing certain video games, Russoniello said, offers just enough mental challenge to keep such people occupied while putting them into a state of relative mindlessness. That state appears to have salutary effects on stress and other mental problems.
Nichols said that she receives no money from PopCap but that the company periodically sends her new games to try, so she can report back on whether they help her fight her depression and post-traumatic stress disorder. (A publicity agent for PopCap put The Post in touch with Nichols.)
Russoniello said that in the next phase of the study, he would randomize patients who meet clinical criteria for depression into two groups. One will be assigned to look up material on the Internet related to mental disorders; the other will be asked to play video games. Russoniello said he wants volunteers who will participate for a month while he studies salivary markers of stress, breathing and heart rhythms. At the end of the month, the volunteers will be evaluated again to see if the video games have had any effect on their symptoms.
Russoniello and several other researchers said that one of the breakthrough ideas in combating stress and other mental disturbances was manipulating a factor known as heart rate variability. Different emotions seem to produce heart rhythm "signatures," and several devices have been invented to measure that variability. Companies such as HeartMath, of Boulder Creek, Calif., have developed video games in which winning requires players to regulate their heart rate variability, thus gaining greater control over their emotional responses to stressful situations.
HeartMath's "emWave" system, for example, has a sensor that can pick up a person's heart rate variability and feed those measurements into a computer. The screen then displays a game that gives people feedback about their heart rhythms and challenges them to play in such a way as to smooth them out. The biofeedback allows people to see how they can control their stress levels through conscious effort.
The company put a Post reporter in touch with Rollin McCraty, a psychophysiologist who directs research at the Institute of HeartMath. He said dozens of studies demonstrate that the intervals between a person's heartbeats are linked with various emotional states.
McCraty said his institute functions as an independent body from the HeartMath company and receives no funding from it, instead seeking out research funds from various grant-making bodies.
McCraty acknowledged that people do not need an electronic system to tell them they are stressed; most people know that already. But he said that people are usually aware when stress levels reach an extreme, not when they are slipping into stress.
Soldiers who have become habituated to being hyper-vigilant may no longer realize that they are not relaxed because their bodies have established a new threshold for "normal." When these soldiers are hooked up to the biofeedback machines, they come to see that even in everyday settings they are stressed out. McCraty is currently studying whether soldiers who learn to control their cardiac rhythms by playing certain video games are better able to perform efficiently under pressure and whether they recover more quickly from traumatic events.
A study among correctional officers funded by California and several studies among nursing staff at leading hospitals have shown that giving people greater control over their internal states allows them to work better and reduces the risk of burnout, according to McCraty.
"Relaxation is not what I am talking about," said McCraty, pointing out that it would be inappropriate to get a soldier in a war zone or a guard at a high-security prison to feel excessively relaxed. "Everyone should learn to relax, but what I am talking about is coherence."
Whether your heart is at 70 or 170 beats per minute, McCraty said, people can learn to have heart rhythms that are coherent or incoherent (equally spaced and smooth, or wavy and haphazard).
While the new tools, games and biofeedback gizmos make it easier to develop control over your heart rate variability, McCraty acknowledged that people could learn to develop smoother heart rhythms without external aids. One system for this, he said, is described at http:/
"We have more power to self-regulate our feelings that most people know," he concluded.