Pulling Ourselves Out of the Crash

We're Halfway Back to the Top. How Much Longer Till We Get There?

NEW YORK

A s far as recovery goes, U.S. stocks appear to be halfway there.

Contrary to warnings by analysts that the market had gone up too much too fast, the rally that began in the spring only accelerated over the summer as investors took on more risk in both the stock and bond markets. The Standard & Poor's 500-stock index now stands at 1071, nearly 400 points above its recent low on March 9.

But the benchmark has almost 500 points to go before it recovers to its October 2007 high, making battered investors whole again.

The force of the surge in equities -- the S&P is up 58 percent since the March low -- came as investors grew more confident that the doomsday scenario of the nationalization of large banks and a prolonged global recession had been avoided. But with consumers hurting and unemployment high, expect the second leg of the healing journey to take much longer, experts say.

"I think we are entering into a period right now of 'Show me,' " said Robert Millen, chairman of Jensen Investment Management. "The market has bounced back dramatically. We're in a real critical period right now where the market's taking a breath and is now starting to pay more attention to fundamentals."

During the past eight recessions, Millen said, the S&P 500 took an average of 1.9 years to recover to the previous high. The fastest recovery time was 83 days, after the 1981-1982 downturn. The longest was 2,114 days, almost six years, after the recession in the mid-1970s.

Analysts will be closely watching the third-quarter corporate earnings results over the next several weeks for clues on just how long this recovery will take.

For his part, Millen says he thinks it could be at least 3 1/2 more years. Some bulls say it could happen sooner. But others say the recent rally is just another bubble in disguise -- not progress toward real recovery.

"We're seeing everything move up," said Axel Merk of Merk Mutual Funds and author of the book "Sustainable Wealth," due out this month. "But that's exactly what we saw in the pre-crisis. . . . Some investors are going to jump on the bandwagon because they want to be a part of this. But this has to have a bad ending."

During the quarter ended Sept. 30, the Dow Jones industrial average of 30 blue-chip stocks jumped 15 percent, to 9712. This is on top of an 11 percent gain in the second quarter. And on Friday, the Dow climbed to its high for 2009, gaining 78 points to hit 9865.

The S&P 500, a broader market measure, finished the third quarter up 15 percent, at 1057. Both benchmarks posted their best quarterly performance in more than a decade. The tech-heavy Nasdaq composite index rose 16 percent.