Supreme Court to hear Uighurs' case
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
The Supreme Court set aside the objections of the Obama administration and said Tuesday that it will consider whether judges have the power to release Guantanamo Bay detainees into the United States if they have been deemed not to be "enemy combatants."
The case, involving a group of Chinese Muslims known as Uighurs, again thrusts the court into the jangle of policy decisions and constitutional principles involving the approximately 220 men still held at the base in Cuba. And the court's decision to hear it could further complicate plans to close the military prison in January, a deadline the Obama administration recently said it might be unable to meet.
Last year, the court ruled 5 to 4 that a Guantanamo detainee had the right to prove to a federal judge that he was being unlawfully held as an enemy combatant. The current case is a logical next step, determining what powers a judge has to release such a person, especially when sending him back to his home country is not an option.
The Obama administration, like the Bush administration, says decisions about releasing detainees are reserved for the executive branch. And both the executive branch and Congress have said that decisions about whether detainees may be shipped to the United States, if there is no other place for them, are reserved for the political branches.
But lawyers for the Uighurs said restricting what judges may do to release those who have won their freedom would make the court's 2008 decision in Boumediene v. Bush meaningless.
"It would be hard to overstate the importance of the question presented in this case -- to the rule of law and to the public," the lawyers wrote in a brief to the court.
Solicitor General Elena Kagan countered in the government's petition that the Boumediene decision "did not purport to address whether detainees who demonstrate an entitlement to release from detention as enemy combatants have a further and distinct constitutional right to enter the United States."
The Justice Department said in a statement Tuesday that it intends to decide by mid-November how it will prosecute remaining Guantanamo prisoners and that the government is proceeding with plans to close the prison. The court's involvement in the Uighur case makes it clear that the administration will need to find policies that suit not only Congress but the court as well.
A case long in waiting
The court has been considering whether to take the case since this spring, and it is not clear why it decided to do so now. Kagan has sent the justices letters saying that a remedy to the situation facing the Uighurs is imminent. The men, captured in Pakistan and Afghanistan in 2001 but now thought to pose no threat to the United States, are considered terrorists by the Chinese government and risk persecution if returned to China.
A federal judge ruled that, if there were no place else to go, the 17 prisoners could be released into this country. That alarmed members of Congress who thought the men might be shipped to their districts, including in Northern Virginia. The area is home to about 300 Uighurs, the largest concentration in the nation.
"The community could help provide support," said Alim Seytoff of the Washington-based Uighur American Association, who hailed the court's decision to take the case. "Seventeen families have offered to open their homes, and just to provide one bedroom for them, so the family could help them with food and help to resettle them."
Congress has restricted the use of federal funds to move the men to the United States.