The Take: Tim Pawlenty hasn't learned from Mitt Romney's 2008 mistakes
Thursday, November 12, 2009
Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty is widely regarded as one of the Republican Party's rising national leaders. The runner-up to Sarah Palin to be John McCain's vice presidential running mate, he is a conservative whose blue-collar roots, amiable personality and two terms as governor of a traditionally Democratic state would seem to make him a natural in attracting the kind of swing voters who are always fought over in presidential elections.
But the Pawlenty who has stepped onto the national stage in recent months has said and done things that have other Republicans wondering about his instincts and his sure-footedness as a prospective 2012 presidential candidate. Pawlenty could learn from the earlier mistakes of one of his potential rivals for the GOP nomination, former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney.
Last week, on MSNBC's "Morning Joe" program, Pawlenty was asked repeatedly whether he welcomed Sen. Olympia Snowe, the lone Republican to vote for the Senate Finance Committee's health-care bill, in the GOP. At a time when some conservatives are insisting on purity within the ranks and others say the party must truly be a big tent, Pawlenty ducked the question. He hemmed and hawed, but couldn't bring himself to say yes -- suggesting that he believed no.
He now calls his responses "an unforced error" and an "inartfully" stated answer. Of course he meant yes, he now insists. "While we don't agree on everything, of course she is welcome in the party," he said in a telephone interview. "That's what I should have said."
His effort to quickly clean up the mess, which included a call to Snowe, helped to make amends. But the misstep was not the first questionable decision by Pawlenty.
In September, he jumped into the controversy over President Obama's speech to schoolchildren, questioning the wisdom of the address in a way that provided some cover to those who claimed that the presidential talk was an overtly political move designed to indoctrinate young people.
In another interview on MSNBC, Pawlenty appeared reluctant to get on the wrong side of those who claimed that there were "death panels" in some versions of the health-care legislation on Capitol Hill. He eventually acknowledged that there were no such panels but said the concerns of those who believed so were justifiable.
On the environment, Politifact.com concluded that he has flip-flopped on climate-change legislation, which he now opposes.
Most recently, Pawlenty endorsed Conservative Party candidate Doug Hoffman over Republican candidate Dede Scozzafava in New York's 23rd congressional district, but he acted only after Palin had turned the special election into an intraparty test of strength.
Pawlenty said there is no deliberate effort to move to the right. "In general, I've governed as a conservative in Minnesota, so being conservative isn't like a new development or a revelation," he said.
He said he raised doubts about Obama's speech to schoolchildren because "I was just echoing what a well-regarded, nonpartisan group of educators [the Minnesota Association of School Boards] was saying." In the New York race, he said, he objected to the fact that Scozzafava was hand-picked by local leaders. He also said he concluded that her views put her far outside the mainstream of Republican doctrine.
"There is certainly room in the party and room in the movement for all kinds of ideas and principles and issue positions," he said, "but in general we have to be rowing in the same direction as a team, and I don't think she met that standard."