Report shows how Montgomery, Fairfax measure up
Wednesday, January 27, 2010
Montgomery County assigned two staffers to peer into the homes and spending accounts of its big neighbor across the Potomac last fall, and the results -- several months and 63 pages of charts and comparative data later -- arrived Tuesday: Fairfax County residents tend to be richer, are taxed less and have 200,000 more local jobs to choose from.
Montgomery (population 951,000) and Fairfax (population 1,015,000) are the behemoths perched beside the nation's capital, and despite the rhetoric and reality of regional cooperation, the two counties keep a close eye on what they view as their biggest competition for jobs and bragging rights.
But they don't usually do their opposition research this methodically or loudly.
Montgomery officials described the effort as a friendly attempt to learn how the Washington region's biggest county manages its affairs. But the burb-on-burb statistical bake-off also represents something of a proxy in the struggle among Montgomery officials over the county's future growth.
"We should not be afraid to assess where we stand," said council member George L. Leventhal (D-At Large), a pro-business legislator who called for the study. "We should recognize the cumulative effects of our policy decisions, including tax, spending and land-use decisions, on our overall competitiveness."
But council member Marc Elrich (D-At Large), who has been more skeptical of county development proposals, said the push for comparisons has limits. "Some people have Fairfax envy," Elrich said. "The question is, should you or should you not have Fairfax envy? And what do you get for it?"
One key measure that Montgomery officials said helped explain the differences in jobs totals was Montgomery's decision decades ago to set aside a vast swath in an agricultural preserve.
The researchers from Montgomery's Office of Legislative Oversight said the county has saved 38 percent of its land in agricultural preservation programs and parkland. Fifteen percent of Fairfax's total area is in parkland, they said.
Meanwhile, Fairfax had 855,842 jobs in 2007, compared with 654,728 in Montgomery, according to the report.
Fairfax Board of Supervisors Chairman Sharon Bulova (D) said she was fascinated with the report but had a quibble: The county's agricultural and forest areas are "closer to the vicinity" of Montgomery's when development limits in the Occoquan watershed are included, she said.
Montgomery officials said they will not shrink the 71,000-acre "agricultural reserve," which has broad political support.
"I believe we must preserve our agricultural reserve forever," Leventhal said. Other areas, though, need a more forceful approach, he said. Votes on two new Planning Board members and a pair of development proposals -- a research-oriented jobs and housing complex near Johns Hopkins University's campus in Gaithersburg and a project near the White Flint Metro station -- will be tests of officials' commitment to spurring economic development, Leventhal said.