Firing of USDA official Shirley Sherrod now under review

By Karen Tumulty and Krissah Thompson
Washington Post Staff Writer
Wednesday, July 21, 2010; 9:07 AM

A fuzzy video of a racially themed speech that prompted the ouster this week of an Agriculture Department official has opened a new front in the ongoing war between the left and right over which side is at fault for stoking persistent forces of racism in politics.

By early Wednesday, as the full context of the video became known, U.S. Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack said he would review his decision to ask USDA official Shirley Sherrod to step down.

Sherrod, a black woman appointed last July as the agency's Georgia state director of rural development, was forced out after a blogger circulated a video showing part of her March 27 appearance at an NAACP banquet. In her speech, Sherrod described an episode in which, while working at a nonprofit organization 24 years ago, she did not help a white farmer as much as she could have. Instead, she said, she sent him to one of "his own kind."

(Richard Cohen: The cowardice of Tom Vilsack)

The video segment was posted Monday on the Web site of conservative activist Andrew Breitbart as a counterattack on the NAACP, which passed a resolution last week accusing the "tea party" movement of having "racist elements."

Late Tuesday, the NAACP released a video recording of the entire speech, including the part when Sherrod describes how she ultimately did assist the farmer. In the process, Sherrod tells her audience, she came to rethink her racial assumptions and conclude that "there is no difference between us."

(Discuss the Shirley Sherrod firing with the reporters of this story)

For some on the right, Sherrod's comments as initially reported reinforced a larger, more sinister narrative: that the administration of the first African American to occupy the White House practices its own brand of racism.

The controversy comes on the heels of another one surrounding the Justice Department's decision to scale back its 2008 voter-intimidation lawsuit against a group known as the New Black Panther Party.

Suspicions on the right that Obama has a hidden agenda -- theories stoked in part by conservative media and sometimes involving race -- have been a subplot of his rise, beginning almost as soon as he announced his campaign. They lie beneath many of the questions that conservatives on the political fringes have raised about his motives, his legitimacy and even his citizenship.

On the other hand, some of the president's allies on the left have at times reflexively seen racism as the real force behind the vehemence of the opposition against Obama's policies and decisions.

The White House has pointedly distanced itself from this line of defense. When Vice President Biden was asked Sunday on ABC about the NAACP resolution regarding the tea party, for instance, he said that racist sentiment exists only at the periphery of the new political movement.

(Jessie Jackson wants an apology for Shirley Sherrod)

"The president doesn't believe that the tea party is a racist organization," Biden said. "I don't believe that. Very conservative, very different views on government and a whole lot of things. But it is not a racist organization."

The sensitivity to Sherrod's comments -- particularly in an agency that has a history of discrimination against minority farmers -- was evidenced by the dispatch with which Vilsack ordered her to resign.

Both Vilsack and an official at the White House denied Sherrod's assertion, in an interview on CNN, that her firing had come at the instigation of the White House. The decision, they insisted, was Vilsack's alone.

"The controversy surrounding her comments would create situations where her decisions, rightly or wrongly, would be called into question, making it difficult for her to bring jobs to Georgia," Vilsack said in a statement.

But in Sherrod's account, her firing was driven more by the exigencies of the news cycle -- and the administration's fear of conservative wrath. She said she was "harassed" to quit by USDA Deputy Undersecretary Cheryl Cook, who told her to "do it, because you're going to be on 'Glenn Beck' tonight."

Sherrod added: "The administration was not interested in hearing the truth."

A video of the full speech -- which runs more than 45 minutes -- shows that Sherrod was trying to make a very different point from the one her critics saw in her inelegantly worded account of the episode with farmer Roger Spooner. An examination of her own prejudice, she said, taught her that those who are struggling have much in common, regardless of race.

"The only difference is the folks with money want to stay in power. It's always about money, y'all," she said. "God helped me to see that it's not just about black people. It's about poor people. I've come a long way."

Ultimately, she did help the farmer -- and on Tuesday, his family was among those who came to her defense. "She's a good friend. She helped us save our farm," Spooner's wife, Eloise, told CNN. "She's the one I give credit for helping us save our farm."

By early Wednesday, Vilsack issued a short statement saying he would reexamine the decision to ask for Sherrod's resignation. "I am of course willing and will conduct a thorough review and consider additional facts to ensure to the American people we are providing services in a fair and equitable manner," Vilsack said.

Sherrod -- who did back-to-back interviews Wednesday morning on the "Today" show and CNN's "American Morning" as the intensive media coverage continued -- called the possibility of a reversal "bittersweet."

"I'm just not sure how I would be treated," if taken back at Agriculture, she said on "Today." "I'm not just not sure at this point."

Sherrod laid some of the blame for the controversial chain of events on the civil rights organization that had sponsored her speech. The NAACP, she told CNN, is "the reason this happened. They got into a fight with the tea party, and this all came out as a result of it."

Breitbart, in fact, subsequently told the network that he had been aware of the video since March and received a copy last weekend.

As for the NAACP, the story put it in the position of reversing itself twice, adding even more of a funhouse-mirror dimension to the brouhaha.

The organization's national office, which did not learn until Tuesday that a local chapter owned the rights to a video of the full speech, on Monday denounced Sherrod's comments as "shameful."

But after reviewing and then releasing the full text of Sherrod's talk, NAACP President Benjamin Jealous declared that "we were snookered" by Sherrod's conservative critics and called for her reinstatement.

Staff writers Ed O'Keefe and Debbi Wilgoren contributed to this report.

© 2010 The Washington Post Company