» This Story:Read +| Comments
Archive   |   Biography   |   RSS Feed   |   Opinions Home   |   Politics Home

The GOP paradox: Strong and yet weak

Network News

X Profile
View More Activity
By David S. Broder
Thursday, September 16, 2010

The end of the primary season arrived Tuesday amid growing signs that a grass-roots rebellion among conservative Tea Party activists may jeopardize Republican prospects for large-scale, recession-fueled gains from the Democrats.

This Story

The stunning defeat of nine-term moderate Rep. Mike Castle, a former governor, by Christine O'Donnell, a previous loser with a troubled personal history who was endorsed by Sarah Palin and the Tea Party movement, in the Delaware Republican Senate primary probably dooms whatever chance the GOP had of capturing Vice President Biden's old Senate seat and, with it, the Senate majority.

The low-turnout upset, coming after similar shocks in Alaska, Nevada, Kentucky and other states, suggests that the shrunken GOP is paying a price for its lack of coherent policy leadership at the national level. But it still may profit in November from the anger of an electorate fixated on the economy and the widespread uncertainty bred by its slow climb back from disaster.

This is the fourth election cycle scarred by a downturn in jobs, savings and profits since Ronald Reagan came to Washington in 1981, and judging from the voter comments I've heard, the psychological damage from this one has been worse than from any of its predecessors.

That is, in part, because it began under George W. Bush and has continued unabated, as far as voters can judge, under Barack Obama. Democrats may claim they have halted the downturn and begun to reverse it, but when you talk to voters -- and local officials -- few see reasons for confidence.

Layoffs and threats of reduced hours and lost income have decimated whole neighborhoods, and local governments' revenue has declined even faster than Washington's -- although the federal deficits are scary enough.

A year ago, it was not clear which party would be more damaged by the fallout from the economic catastrophe. But now it is evident that, somewhere along the way, Obama and the Democrats lost control of the dialogue, and the populist backlash focused on big government, rather than big business.

Because the Democrats so visibly put their stamp on that government in 2006 and 2008, attracting vast attention with the elections of the first female speaker of the House and the first black president, they are destined to take the brunt of the anti-Washington protests.

Thus, the biggest paradox of the 2010 campaign year -- that Republicans are poised for major gains, even though their reputation as a party has not really recovered from the Bush years and there is no evidence that voters think they have developed better ideas than the Democrats have for improving the economy.

Because the GOP image remains so weak nationally under Michael Steele, Mitch McConnell and John Boehner, states have been flirting all year with the danger that their primaries will produce candidates reflecting the internal dynamics of right-wing constituencies scary to the broader electorate.

That has happened already in the Colorado governor's race and the Nevada Senate contest against Majority Leader Harry Reid. And it happened again Tuesday in Delaware and in New York, where a Tea Party candidate for governor won.

It is likely to surface as a challenging dynamic when Republicans turn to the choice of a 2012 presidential nominee. With Sarah Palin helping foment rebellions within GOP ranks in states from Alaska and Utah to Florida and Delaware, it may be harder than usual for the Republican establishment to anoint a front-runner from its own ranks.

On the other hand, this year's primaries have given Republicans candidates for governor capable of winning in states such as Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois, Wisconsin, Michigan, Iowa, Oregon and especially California, to add to Texas, Georgia and perhaps Florida, which they already hold. This could enhance the reputation of the GOP as a governing party beyond measure.

Democrats can still affect the outcome, but under the spell of Obama, they have lost the opportunity to debate big issues among themselves. Their next chance will come after Nov. 2, when the Obama administration reconstitutes itself.

davidbroder@washpost.com

For more Post Opinions on the primary results, read E.J. Dionne Jr. on Mike Castle's defeat and the end of moderate Republicanism, Eugene Robinson's Tea Party win, GOP loss, Ruth Marcus on Christine O'Donnell's scary victory, Richard Cohen on the GOP's primary-night putsch and Colbert King on How Vincent Gray beat Adrian Fenty.


» This Story:Read +| Comments

More Washington Post Opinions

PostPartisan

Post Partisan

Quick takes from The Post's opinion writers.

Washington Sketch

Washington Sketch

Dana Milbank writes about political theater in the capital.

Tom Toles

Tom Toles

See his latest editorial cartoon.

© 2010 The Washington Post Company

Network News

X My Profile