First Bite

Donna is back, hoping the third time's a charm

"I feel 25 again," says chef Roberto Donna, whose Galileo III opened last week with a menu of two dozen dishes. (Bill O'leary)
  Enlarge Photo    
tom sietsema
Wednesday, October 13, 2010

After countless delays and more drama than you can find in an entire season of "True Blood," Galileo III finally opened Oct. 4. The long-awaited Italian restaurant is a nod to two earlier Washington dining rooms of the same name, both helmed by veteran chef Roberto Donna, 49.

It's impossible to write about the arrival of Galileo III, which Donna initially pegged for a spring 2009 launch, without mentioning the elephant in the room. That would be Donna's recent headline-making run-ins with Arlington County, for failing to pay meal taxes at his late Bebo Trattoria in Crystal City, and in the District, where he has faced lawsuits from former employees and investors. Food followers could be forgiven for thinking Donna wasn't ever going to pull off the project.

But here he is - a little rounder and a shade grayer than when we saw him last - tasting and directing and cooking in a new open kitchen that puts him back on stage for the first time since Bebo was shuttered last year.

"I'm persistent," the 1996 James Beard award winner says when asked about the skepticism surrounding the debut of Galileo III. His return, he says, is "like coming out of a black tunnel. I feel 25 again."

His dinner menu is two dozen dishes long and includes much that will be familiar to anyone who dined at the previous Galileo on 21st Street NW, which closed four years ago. On one hand, it's a treat to be reacquainted with Donna's pink round of pork sausage bedded on lentils, and tender stamp-size pasta stuffed with chicken, veal and pork and sauced with butter and fresh sage. Others might feel as though the distractions in his life kept him from coming up with fresher ideas.

Donna says that "people are going to ask for" his previous hits even if they're not listed on a piece of paper, so he might as well offer them. And to be fair, among his new seductions is a savory pudding with the texture of creme caramel. Flavored with Parmigiano-Reggiano, the custard is gilded with fresh burrata and porcini cream before serving. Like the salad showcasing tuna three ways (raw, smoked and as dried roe), the pudding disappears quickly, unlike the listless lamb and beef entrees that follow.

Diners pass a convivial bar before descending to a sunken, 80-seat dining room, warm in orange and brown. Donna says he asked his designer to "take out everything that makes you tense." Among the sunny appointments in the restaurant is Nancy Sabbagh, the chef's wife and roaming goodwill ambassador.

600 14th St. NW. 202-783-0083. Fixed-price dinners from $55 (three courses) to $89 (five courses).

© 2010 The Washington Post Company