Dissatisfaction in federal employee pay sign of disconnect
Monday, October 18, 2010; 8:32 PM
Like the late bug-eyed comic Rodney Dangerfield, federal employees sometimes get no respect.
The Washington Post poll published in Monday's paper reflects that.
Among those who said they had contact with a federal employee, a whopping 73 percent said the worker did a good job, yet 52 percent of everyone surveyed said federal employees are overpaid. How can that be?
Another thing, if satisfaction with Frankie and Flo Fed is so high, then how can 49 percent of respondents say Uncle Sam's staff doesn't work as hard as private sector workers?
And despite officials figures showing federal work in general pays 22 percent less than private sector jobs, 75 percent say federal workers get better pay and benefits.
John Berry, director of the Officer of Personnel Management, was steaming over that last point.
He said he was frustrated that "the Heritage and Cato misinformation campaign has obviously gained traction." The two Washington, D.C., think tanks have produced widely discussed reports indicating that federal workers are paid too much. A "pretty prolonged misinformation campaign over the last six month leading up to this," he said, "has worked."
His words were echoed by union leaders. Said William R. Dougan, president of the National Federation of Federal Employees: "If you tell people the same lies enough times, eventually they will start to believe them. Federal workers are not overpaid; they make significantly less than those doing the same work in the private sector. In fact, President Bush concurred with this assessment in each of his years in office. But some will not let facts get in the way of a good talking point."
Added Matthew S. Biggs, legislative director for the International Federation of Professional & Technical Engineers: "Normally one would think that scapegoating dedicated federal workers who have dedicated careers to serving the American public would be beyond reproach. However, perceived political gain at the expense of dedicated public servants is more important to the GOP leadership."
Before the polling results were released, I asked President Obama about complaints that federal employees are overpaid. His reaction was more measured than Berry's or the union leaders', perhaps because they awoke to a headline questioning the work ethic of federal employees.
"Well, I've had my team look at this, and the data we get back indicates that high-skilled workers in government are slightly underpaid; lower-skilled workers are slightly overpaid, relative to the private sector," Obama said in a Friday meeting with the Trotter Group, an organization of black columnists.
He attributed that, in part, to the unionization of federal workers. Federal unions, however, do not bargain over wages, as private sector unions do. But federal unions can play a powerful role with Congress and the White House, where the final pay decisions are made.