The Fix: Attack on Rand Paul reverberates
A new ad being run by state Attorney General Jack Conway (D) against ophthalmologist Rand Paul (R) in the Kentucky Senate race using several college-era incidents to raise questions about the Republican's character has created a national firestorm.
"Why was Rand Paul a member of a secret society that called the Holy Bible a 'hoax'," asks the ad's narrator. "Why did Rand Paul once tie a woman up, tell her to bow down before a false idol and say his god was 'Aqua Buddha'."
The ad's charges both can be traced back to Paul's collegiate years.
In the "Aqua Buddha" incident -- and, no, we never thought we would write those words (at least not together) in this blog -- Paul vehemently denied being involved in any kidnapping, saying only that he went along with a college prank. (The woman involved told Greg Sargent, who writes the "Plum Line" blog, that the "whole thing has been blown out of proportion.")
The "anti-Christian" charge comes from Paul's membership in a secret society while at Baylor University that published mocking statements regarding the Bible in newsletters.
"This is an ad about things he did," said Conway campaign manager John Collins of the allegations in the ad. "He has failed to deny any of these charges."
Paul, for his part, struck back with an ad own his own in which a narrator says he keeps "Christ in his heart" and attacks Conway for bearing "false witness".
Regardless of the veracity of either/both of the charges, the ad amounts to a major gamble for Conway. Down only a handful of points in most public polling, it now seems clear that this ad could make or break the race -- forcing voters to decide whether Paul's college transgressions are fair game in the context of a political race or whether Conway went too far and, in so doing, made himself look like a desperate candidate looking for a Hail Mary political pass.
Recent political history provides a mixed bag when seeking to assess which way this Conway ad will play with voters.
The most obvious comparison to the Paul ad is one that then Sen. Elizabeth Dole (R-N.C.) ran against state Sen. Kay Hagan (D) in the waning days of the 2008 North Carolina Senate race.
Late in October 2008, Dole when she launched what is now commonly known as the "Godless American" ad -- insinuating that Hagan's attendance at a fundraiser sponsored by a leader of the Godless Americans PAC raised questions about her religious beliefs.
Hagan, smartly, responded with a commercial of her own accusing Dole of "bearing false witness against fellow Christians." (Sound familiar?)