Often, extended warranty won't extend your satisfaction

By Pat Mertz Esswein
Sunday, January 9, 2011

Before you sign up for extended warranty coverage, make sure you're getting the protection you pay for.

Retailers love these contracts. In fact, retailers might reap more profit from extended warranties on appliances and major electronics than they do on the products themselves (that's why salespeople are coached to urge you to buy the extra coverage). Typically, you'll pay 10 to 20 percent more for an item to extend a one-year manufacturer's warranty through the fifth year of ownership, according to the Service Contract Industry Council. Most retailers hand off the contract to a third-party administrator in exchange for up to half of what you paid.

Odds are you won't need it. Celia Kuperszmid Lehrman of Consumer Reports says that most major appliances do not break down within the extended-warranty period (among the exceptions are refrigerators with icemakers, electric wall ovens and dishwashers). When they do, she adds, the cost of repair roughly equals the cost of the extended warranty.

You might already be covered. American Express cards extend the length of the manufacturer's warranty by up to one year, and Visa Signature and most MasterCard credit cards will double it. Costco extends manufacturers' warranties on TVs, projectors and computers to two years from the date of purchase. Plus, the manufacturer may provide a free or discounted fix for a defect that doesn't reach the level of a product recall.

Service? What service? Timothy Meenan, executive director of the SCIC, says that with an extended warranty, you step to the front of the line. But Steve Sheinkopf of Yale Appliance and Lighting in Boston says he sells and services his own extended warranties because most third-party administrators do not respond quickly to customer complaints. William Purdy, a factory-authorized appliance repairman in Telluride, Colo., says he's found that administrators pay low and slow and demand burdensome paperwork.

It's easy to check the provider's track record. If you're considering an extended warranty, ask upfront who will provide service. Vet the provider online, using a source such as Angie's List. Read the contract and look for deductibles, limits to the number of covered service calls, exclusions to coverage and triggers for cancellation. (If the appliance can't be fixed after a reasonable number of attempts, will it be replaced?) Then check the administrator's record with your state insurance department and the Better Business Bureau. For instance, Assurant, which administers extended warranties for such manufacturers as Whirlpool and KitchenAid, gets an A, the top rating. Warrantech, which sells the RepairMaster warranty through retail appliance dealers and online dealer AJ Madison, gets an F, largely because of lengthy delays in providing service.

You can cancel. If you bought an extended warranty, most states mandate a 30-day "free look" period (some contracts provide up to 90 days) during which you can cancel and receive a full refund. (To learn more, contact your state's consumer protection department.) You may still cancel after that, but you'll receive a prorated refund, and the administrator might charge you a fee.

- Kiplinger's Personal Finance

© 2011 The Washington Post Company