Restrictions on alcohol ads on billboards hurriedly replaced by Virginia Assembly
RICHMOND - Legislators who've been scrambling to write last-minute restrictions for alcohol ads on residential billboards say they are angry that the governor did not tell them sooner about a lawsuit that resulted in Virginia lifting a long-standing ban.
Lawmakers learned about the suit last week, although the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control quietly entered into a consent decree Jan. 7 with billboard company Lamar with the approval of Gov. Robert F. McDonnell (R) and Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli II (R).
"For some reason, they didn't think it was important for them to tell us,'' said Del. David B. Albo (R-Fairfax), who sits on a House committee that oversees alcohol laws. "This is not the best way to do work."
Some legislators have complained to the governor's staff about what they perceive as a slight and have suggested that it was because McDonnell did not want to jeopardize his push to privatize the state's liquor stores after months of lobbying lawmakers.
"If we can't give the public confidence that we're not going to change the advertising for alcohol in Virginia, then it's going to have a negative impact on the ability to privatize ABC stores,'' said Del. G. Glenn Oder (R-Newport News), chairman of the House general laws subcommittee that oversees ABC laws.
McDonnell's proposal died during this year's legislative session, with Democrats and Republicans opposed. But the governor is expected to return next year with a revamped plan to end the state's 77-year-old monopoly on distilled spirits.
His director of policy, Eric Finkbeiner, said the governor's office routinely enters into agreements on a variety of issues that it does not inform legislators about.
"This had zero to do with ABC privatization,'' Finkbeiner said. "It was either come up with this compromise or have no restrictions, because the likelihood of us losing in court was significant."
60-year rule changed
Lamar sued Virginia in September, arguing that the state's advertising restrictions violated its freedom of speech. The settlement required the state to lift its 60-year ban on alcohol ads on billboards and also suspended many other limits until the ABC could write new regulations for court approval.
Now in the final few days of the annual General Assembly session, legislators are trying to pass a bill to return some control to the state by restricting alcohol ads on billboards in certain places.
The House of Delegates voted 97-0 Wednesday for an emergency bill that would allow liquor billboards in industrial and commercial areas but would ban them within 500 feet of schools, houses, places of worship or parks.
The Senate unanimously passed the bill Thursday.