Sudarsan Raghavan on Egypt-inspired demonstrations in Bahrain, Yemen

Network News

X Profile
View More Activity
Sudarsan Raghavan
Tuesday, February 15, 2011; 12:00 PM

Washington Post Africa Bureau Chief Sudarsan Raghavan will be online Tuesday, Feb. 15, at noon, to talk about how the events in Egpyt have sparked clashes in Yemen, Bahrain and Iran.

_______________________

Sudarsan Raghavan: Hi Everyone, Glad to be here, and I look forward to your questions. So fire away!

_______________________

Egypt vs. Bahrain/Iran/Yemen: What makes Egypt different than the other countries? How do the demonstrations themselves differ? How exactly do protesters organize themselves?

Sudarsan Raghavan: But unlike Egypt, Yemen has a smaller middle class, high rates of illiteracy, and a weak civil society. Internet penetration is very low here, so the use of Facebook, Twitter and social media that organized and fueled Egypt's rebellion is very limited in Yemen. In addition, there's a division between Yemen's political opposition and the protesters, mostly students and activists, we have seen on the streets. The political opposition wants reforms while the protesters want regime change. This is another reason why we have not seen the sort of momentum here as we have in Egypt. The demonstrators tend to organize themselves through text messages and simple word of mouth, although there is growing use of Facebook.

_______________________

Internet/cellphone access: How tightly controlled is internet access and cellphone use in Iran, Bahrain and Yemen? Will that information control play a role in protests?

Sudarsan Raghavan: In Iran, we have seen the hardliners calling for the arrest, even the execution, of opposition protesters. I can only imagine that they are also clamping down on the Internet, especially Facebook, which Iranian activists widely used to mobilize during their uprisings in 2009. Meanwhile, Bahrain's King Hamad bin Isa al-Khalifa made a rare national TV address, promised to loosen state controls on the media and Internet, a clear sign that like he's considered that uprisings could spawn an Egypt-like revolt.

_______________________

Army loyalty: The Egyptian army either was not told to use force, or told the government they would not fire on the public. It seems that was a key tipping point. Where do you think the armies in Yemen, UAE and Iran will line up - government or public?

Sudarsan Raghavan: In Iran, convesntinal wisdom would say that the military and the Iranian Revolutionary Guard will side with the hardliners in the government. But, as Egypt and Tunisia have shown, there have been many surprises. Who would have thought Egypt's military generals would side with the people and push out Hosni Mubarak, a man they have long been indebted to ?

_______________________

Shia versus sunni strife: Isn't it a problem that both Yemen and Bahrain have shia majorities, but ruled by the sunni minority? Since Iran is the only Shia muslim country in the world, wouldn't democracy in both these two countries bring them closer to Iran, and move them away from Saudi Arabia and the West?

Sudarsan Raghavan:

_______________________

IRG and Ayatollahs: Can the Ayatollahs in Iran still count on the Iranian Revolutionary Guard to suppress the public? I've read there may be splits with the IRG over this. It seems to me that without their total support, the Ayatollahs risk the demonstrations going beyond their control, and their power would be at risk.

Sudarsan Raghavan: We are witnessing an event unlike anything this region has experienced in recent memory.

_______________________

role of america: In the USA, Democrats believe the election of a Muslim-rooted president is providing a role model for young educated Muslims around the world that they can achieve anything. Republicans are calling this the fruit of the previous President's commitment not to leave that port of the world behind the march to democracy. Do the demonstrators you talk to see America as an important part of their inspiration, or an irrelevancy to long-dormant complaints?

Sudarsan Raghavan: are ones inspired by American values.

_______________________

The Big Picture: Do you have a sense of how organized and prescient these revolutions/protests are? It's one thing to just protest the status quo and/or overthrow the current leader/despot; it's quite another to have a forthright plan in place for the aftermath--one group wants representative democracy, another winner-take-all democracy, another sharia, another Marxism, etc. Frankly, can I trust the Egyptian military to effectively transition to a democratic leadership over a year or two, or could we just see a junta replacing Mubarak long-term?

Sudarsan Raghavan: worried about the latter scenario. But at the same time, the streets have gained a new and formidable power, and many here say that if they don't get a civilian, democractic government that has been elected free and fairly, they will again take to the streets.

_______________________

Political Parties in Egypt: The Muslim Brotherhood has announced, as expected, that they will form a political party in Egypt. How will other competing political parties form to provide an alternative, especially given the limited amount of time until elections may be called?

Sudarsan Raghavan: Because of this, many of its leaders say six months is more than enough for free and fair elections. But for other political leaders, that's not the case. Some say that Egypt needs as long as two years to hold elections, so that viable political parties can emerge and campaign on a level playing field. We'll certainly going to see a lot of political and ideological realignments and compromises between various groups that is likely to transform the egyptian political landscape unlike anything we have seen.

_______________________

Bahrain in the mid term: I sent a question an hour or so ago. It pertains to my daughter signing a two year contract in Bahrain for a kindergarden teaching position. The school is Kardoon in the capital. Should she go ahead?

Sudarsan Raghavan: I suggest contacting the US embassy or the school itself, asking what conditions are like, are expatriates being targeted and, if so, what sort of protective measures are in place.

_______________________

corruption: How difficult is it going to be for the Egyptians to get the corruption out of their system? By all accounts it is very entrenched. I guess revolutions are messy things. This isn't going to be a clean, easy, quick process or transition is it?

Sudarsan Raghavan: Hard to say, but certainly the rampant corruption has been a key elements that drove the rebellion. So I imagine any future government will be elected only if it pledges to root out graft. But you're right. Changing a mindset and attitude that is deeply rooted over decades is not going to be clean or easy. Nor will it unfold quickly.

_______________________

Sudarsan Raghavan: cheers,Sudarsan


© 2011 The Washington Post Company

Discussion Archive

Viewpoint is a paid discussion. The Washington Post editorial staff was not involved in the moderation.

Network News

X My Profile