What the Oscar Drama Needs Is Some Comic Relief
Sunday, February 17, 2008; Page M03
If you want to win an Academy Award, for goodness' sake don't sing, dance or make 'em laugh.
At least that seems to be the unspoken truth around Oscar time. When it comes to winning Best Picture -- heck, even snagging a nomination -- comedies and musicals usually take a back seat. Way back.
Take a quick mental scroll down the list of winners since 1927, when the first Academy Award ceremonies were held. You'll see serious, serious and more serious. By my count, only 10 musicals have taken the top prize, including "The Great Ziegfeld," "Gigi" and more recently, "Chicago."
There have been some great comedies that took the big prize over recent decades, including 1960's "The Apartment," 1963's "Tom Jones" and 1977's "Annie Hall." But only 13 statuette holders in total can vaguely be termed comedies, assuming we count "laff riots" such as "American Beauty," "Shakespeare in Love" and "Driving Miss Daisy."
This year, hope springs futile again: Johnny Depp has been nominated for his performance in the musical "Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street." The sorta-romantic comedy "Juno" is up for Best Picture, with lead actress Ellen Page getting a nod. But "Enchanted," the music-laced comedy, has had to settle for three nominations in the Best Song category. We'd like to think the Disney film has a fighting chance but we know, for the most part, "The Wizard of Oz" is always going to lose to "Gone With the Wind."
So filmmakers of musicals and comedies must look to the Golden Globes, which offers that strange hybrid category known as "Comedy/Musical." (How, exactly, do you judge the merits of "Sweeney Todd" against "Juno," anyway? The Globers chose "Sweeney.")
C'mon, Oscar. In 2001, you rolled out a new award for feature-length animation. Why not extend the fun and the credit where it's due? Let's have a slot for Best Comedy. And Best Musical. Separate from each other. And if you're feeling magnanimous, we'll take some acting categories, too. Yes, for both genres. That way, Johnny comes marching home with an Oscar for his role in "Sweeney Todd." And that cute Ellen Page gets her prize for "Juno," so Julie Christie can walk away with something for "Away From Her."
The Emmys and Television Critics Association Awards have separate categories for comedy and drama, notes Tom O'Neil, entertainment blogger and author of the book "Movie Awards." And the Screen Actors Guild Awards differentiate between the two for television performances, but not for movie roles.
O'Neil calls it a classic double standard: "With film we feel we have to lump them together, which proves Hollywood has no sense of humor."
Mixing up comedies, musicals and dramas in the Best Picture slot "makes for an uncomfortable blend," says Mike Goodridge, U.S. editor of Screen International, and a member of the Hollywood Foreign Press Association, which sponsors the Golden Globes. "When you're trying to decide between 'Goodfellas' and 'Ghost' [Best Picture nominees for 1990] or 'Beauty and the Beast' and 'The Silence of the Lambs' [ditto for 1991], it's always going to be a dilemma. . . . People tend to vote for the dark, brooding dramas."
Barry Josephson, producer of "Enchanted," says that in this era in which "darker dramas" seem to take precedent "it's almost impossible for a comedy or musical to be nominated. I don't think 'Mary Poppins' or 'The Sound of Music' gets nominated. But those movies entertain audiences in a big way. They deserve nominations the way Billy Wilder used to."
A new category for musicals or comedy, he says, "would be a very popular category not just with the Academy voters but for the people who watch the awards."