Apple Store Design Hits a Glass Wall Again
Friday, February 6, 2009; Page B04
An architectural review board yesterday ordered Apple to redraw plans for a store in Georgetown, the fourth time it has rejected the company's submission.
The Old Georgetown Board told Apple's architect that it is eager for the store to open on Wisconsin Avenue. But the three members, all architects, expressed disappointment that Apple keeps proposing a design that they have criticized.
In the latest rendering, Apple proposed a storefront that is a 35-foot-wide pane of glass with a door. During previous rounds, the board said that was inconsistent with neighboring properties' detailing and bay windows. "We're frustrated a little bit because we haven't gotten a response to our fairly consistent request," board member David Cox told Apple's architect, Karl Backus.
Backus assured the board that Apple is not "purposefully ignoring your suggestions," although he noted that a glass expanse is standard for many of the company's storefronts, symbolizing its belief in transparency. Still, he said he would return with a new design proposal that would incorporate the board's suggestions.
Apple's struggles to win the board's support have fueled concerns among merchants and city officials over how long the company is taking to open a store that it began planning at least two years ago.
Neil O. Albert, deputy mayor for planning and economic development, said in a statement that "we're extremely disappointed with today's decision."
"The community and the Fenty administration are very supportive of this retailer opening its Georgetown store," he said. "I'll move quickly to convene separate meetings with the Old Georgetown Board and Apple representatives to reach a consensus design."
Amy Bessette, an Apple spokeswoman, said in an e-mail that the company remains committed to "bringing the unique Apple retail experience to Georgetown."
In 2007, Apple paid more than $13 million for the three-story building on Wisconsin Avenue. The building is 24 years old but it is within a historic district with buildings more than 100 years old.
Apple plans to raze the building and put up a store, joining 251 retail outlets it has around the world, including five in the Maryland and Virginia suburbs.
But first it must win the approval of the Old Georgetown Board, which is overseen by the U.S. Commission of Fine Arts.
Apple submitted its first renderings to the board in September 2007, a two-story building with five windows across the second floor and an expansive show window. The board told Apple that the ground-floor window was out of scale with neighboring storefronts.