Senator should release hold on blocking federal oversight of Metro system

Washington Post columnist Robert McCartney talks to TBD's Dave Lucas about his column criticizing Sen. Tom Coburn (R-Okla.) for blocking a federal transit safety bill.
Thursday, August 12, 2010

Lots of controversies swirl around Metro and its safety problems, but there's widespread agreement on one thing: The federal government should get the same powers to set safety standards for subways that it has for Amtrak and commuter trains.

But the agreement isn't unanimous.

U.S. Sen. Tom Coburn (R) of Oklahoma, whose state doesn't have a subway, is using one of those notorious Senate "holds" to block a bill with strong bipartisan support that would give the Federal Transit Administration powers that might have prevented last year's fatal Red Line crash.

His action threatens passage of common-sense legislation backed even by agencies and companies in the industry it would regulate, including Metro. Coburn objects to creating a new government program with added spending, but the money is a pittance compared to the need: $66 million over three years, which would represent a whopping one dollar out of every 500 in the FTA's budget.

If the bill dies, as some supporters expect, it would illustrate how dysfunctional our political system has become. In a narrow sense, it would be another example of the abuse of holds, a form of senatorial privilege that allows a single senator to prevent a bill from going to the floor for consideration. Coburn is one of the Senate's leading offenders.

More broadly, the bill's demise would illustrate how our wariness of government can reach self-destructive extremes. Hostility to the public sector runs so strong that some conservatives object to any expansion of its powers, even when nonpartisan experts such as the National Transportation Safety Board say lives are at stake.

The bill would be a plus for the Washington region, because it would help make sure that the Metro board and local politicians follow through on their promises to raise Metro's safety standards.

Metro is making all the right noises now, in the wake of the tough NTSB report faulting the system for the crash north of the Fort Totten Station in Northeast.

At an unprecedented meeting Monday with the NTSB, Metro board members seemed to want to hear what the safety experts had to say about how they could do better. The atmosphere was surprisingly civil, considering that NTSB Chairman Deborah A.P. Hersman had called Metro "tone deaf" over safety.

Fixing the system's problems is going to take years, though. One way to ensure that Metro sticks to the task would be to designate the federal government as the enforcer.

The absurdity of the existing situation is evident at Fort Totten. The federal government enforces safety standards for two tracks there used by Amtrak and MARC, but not for the two used by Metro.

The Senate bill would empower the FTA to do things such as set standards for the crashworthiness of railcars and timetables for the mandatory removal of unsafe ones. Fewer people would have died or been hurt in the Red Line crash if Metro had upgraded its railcars, as the NTSB had recommended.

CONTINUED     1        >

© 2010 The Washington Post Company