washingtonpost.com
Home   |   Register               Web Search: by Google
channel navigation


 News Home Page
 News Digest
 Nation
 World
 Metro
 Business
 Market News
 Portfolio
 Technology
 Company Research
 Mutual Funds
 Personal Finance
 Industries
 Columnists
 Special Reports
 Live Online
 Business Index
 Washtech
 Sports
 Style
 Education
 Travel
 Health
 Home & Garden
 Opinion
 Weather
 Weekly Sections
 Classifieds
 Print Edition
 Archives
 Site Index
Help
Partners:


Summary
  JCPenney Sears.com Target.com Walmart.com Costco Online
SITE: jcpenney.com sears.com target.com walmart.com costco.com
PRODUCTS: Full-line retailer. Full-line retailer. Full-line discount store. Full-line discount store. Membership warehouse store.
BEST FOR:             
PLUS: Some "virtual models," consumer-product recall archive. Great appliance, electronic and workshop advice; consumer-product recall archive. Great, well-designed stuff. Home page is a no-nonsense directory-boom, you're there; deep, deep inventory; super-enlarged pictures of items; cheap gift wrap and shipping. Incredible surprises; great buys; consumer-product recall archive.
MINUS: Stocks few hot brand names except in electronics. This is one ugly site with a truly lousy search function; currently no gift wrap. Quirky search function. Almost overwhelming in size. Small number of (great) items; no gift wrap. Non-members pay 5% more.
ORDER BY: Dec. 19 (Dec. 21 for pickup at Penney's or Eckerd drugstores). Not posted. Dec. 18. Not yet decided by site. Not posted.
BOTTOM LINE: This is a fast, well-organized site for middle-of-the-road goods. A Penney's dilemma: There are no fancy fashion names here, but full-bore department store prices, including $6 gift wrap. All the incredible strengths and baffling weaknesses of the real live Sears: More appliances than anyone else and terrific tools, paired with kitschy "collectibles" and infomercial-variety cookware. This is the "cool" discount site, where graphics rule. But maybe the art directors were given a little too much say. The search function doesn't pick up the Harry Potter stuff unless you type only "Potter." If Amazon hears heavy footsteps behind it, here's the 800-pound gorilla making the noise. Relaunched two weeks ago, this is the whole superstore, minus the laundry detergent and paper towels, online. No other site I know of has a $5,800 Breguet watch, a Kohler toilet, a smoked turkey and a car waxer within four mouse clicks of one another. (By the way, the watch's suggested retail is about $8,000.)
SUMMARY:

Move over, Amazon.com, the big boys of retailing are finally online in a big way. Uh, Amazon? Would ya scoot over just a little bit?

The big five arrive with well-known personalities and the convenience of making returns to a local store. I'm crazy about Target.com, the hip discounter. Who says less expensive goods have to look nasty? And Costco? Just like the warehouses (replacement tires two aisles away from the Perrier-Jouet), it's always good for a thrill. The past few weeks it was six Baccarat "Massena" red wine glasses for $529.99 (that's about $200 off, folks). Not for nothing does the site have a "treasure hunt" category.

But you have to wonder who's minding the store at Sears. There are two cluttered sites tucked inside each other, Sears.com (tools, lawn and garden) and Wishbook.com (the Sears catalogue minus the "softer side"), but nowhere is this explained. And what's with the picture labels, "Image shown may differ from actual product appearance"? Excuse me?

JCPenney.com is easy to use, even fun, but at the end of the day it's the merchandise that counts. Without the flashy brand names, and stuff people really want, they just may not stick around. Same goes for Wal-mart.com. Do these sites have everything you want to give for Christmas? For a lot of people the answer will be yes; for others, no.

The other discounter entry is Kmart's Bluelight.com, with as cluttered a home page as Sears.com but in a more cheerful palette and, for some reason, quite inviting. Bluelight.com has Celebration Barbie (about $30) just like most of the others, but remember, it also has . . . Martha!

And now, tiptoeing up behind the behemoths, come Macys.com, Bloomingdales.com (also Bloomies.com, thank goodness), Saksfifthavenue.com and Neimanmarcus.com. These merchants clearly see themselves as editors of merchandise, not warehouses of same. My advice? Forget the baffling categories and just browse.

-Nancy McKeon

Other Category Comparison Charts:
Dep't Stores | Beauty | Books | Clothing | Computers | Electronics | Food | Movies | Music | Toys

Online Holiday Shopping Stories:
Return to the Lead story, or read about: Decking the Halls With a Mouse; Avoiding Pitfalls; Shopbots; Foreign Purchases; Online Greetings; Customizing Gifts; Comparison Shopping

© 2000 The Washington Post Company