"Titanic": Smackdown

Dan Zak swoons over star-crossed lovers on a ship of doom. Melissa Bell tries to hold back her lunch. One loves it. One loathes it. As "Titanic" steams back into our lives in 3D, let the great debate begin.

Note: Sign-in before voting. You can only vote and make your argument once! Make it count. You can reply and recommend other arguments as much as you like.

Have your say:

Is "Titanic" art, or junk?

Art %

It impeccably ennobles the genre of epic romance. We'll never let go.

Junk %

It is an iceberg in the ocean of American culture. Drown, baby, drown.