| If You Are a(n) |
Then Consider |
Or |
But Not |
NOTES |
Infrequent Flyer Up to 4 trips a year, various destinations |
US Airways, TWA Because miles never expire |
Delta One flight per three years retains miles
|
United, American Mile expirations firm
|
US Airways, with most flights from area, is best for slow accumulators. TWA offers 750-miles-per-trip minimum and low award minimums, but few local flights.
|
Moderate Flier Around 6 trips a year, including some to West Coast
|
United, Delta, American The best, most flexible programs |
US Airways Award program less rich, but dominates local air traffic |
TWA, Continental Fewer local flights yield fewer options for occasional flier
|
American, United miles expire most quickly; Delta better for less-frequent fliers. United, Continental require Saturday night stay for award trips. US Airways loses points for for summer European award restrictions. |
Shuttler 8-plus trips a year via NY/Boston shuttles. Under 4 trips a year via other routes
|
Delta Has the superior awards programs, but fewer local flights to other destinations |
US Airways More local departures than Delta; adding direct-to-Boston shuttle in '98
|
N/A |
Shuttle round trips earn 1000 miles. Consequently, less frequent but longer trips -- twice-yearly West Coast jaunts, say -- may build more miles than frequent shuttling. See above note about US Airways' summer European rules; US Airways offers no Hawaii award travel. |
| If You Are a(n) |
Then Consider |
Or |
But Not |
NOTES |
Corporate Tool 6 trips a year for business; 4 a year for leisure, family
|
United, American, Continental
|
Delta, US Airways Only if shuttling is a big part of your travel
|
TWA, Northwest Fewest local departures of major lines
|
American is best for couples and non-flying awards -- but (like US Airways) it blacks out summer award travel to Europe. Delta is stingier with upgrades than American, United; Continental has fewer local departures.
|
International Coporate Tool Same as above, plus 1 or 2 international trips a year
|
United, American Best reach, flexibility, partners in global routes, awards
|
Delta Stingier with upgrades, offer fewer local flights than United, American
|
Continental International awards, partners not as good as top three |
American is best for couples and for earning non-flying awards -- but it blacks out summer award travel to Europe.
|
Road Warrior 12-plus trips a year; wants upgrades, perks
|
United Very-frequent-fliers' perennial favorite
|
American Best for non-air mile accumulation
|
N/A
|
United offers twice as many departures from local airports as American or Delta. Nearly every program showers upgrades, perks upon this crowd.
|
| If You Are a(n) |
Then Consider |
Or |
But Not |
NOTES |