Usually I’d just ask my friend for clarity, but I also don’t want to be That Demanding Guest. If my boyfriend were included, we’d probably go, otherwise I probably won’t. How do I broach this with my friend, without being That Person?
— Not That Demanding Guest
Not That Demanding Guest: Just don’t go. If this friend were close enough and your interest in being at her wedding were strong enough, then you’d go solo. And, if you felt comfortable enough with her and with your friendship to talk about it openly, then you already would have done it.
I put out a call for alternate viewpoints, especially from brides or grooms who would want to be asked. Here’s a sampling of the responses:
· I would want to be asked, but I’m generally the more-the-merrier type. Also, if it was on purpose (the wedding is small, for example, and they don’t know him), can he come to the destination but not go to the wedding? Do the beach/sightseeing/etc. on his own that day?
· Nope, don’t ask. If I wanted your boyfriend at my wedding, I would have asked you for his name or left a blank space for his RSVP. Otherwise, assume he’s not invited.
· Ask if it was intentional and be prepared to accept the yes without pressure for it to be a different answer. I addressed a wedding invite to a friend that included her son on the inner envelope and didn’t realize I’d left his name off the outer envelope. I am really glad she checked in rather than just not come.
· Wedding planning is HARD, and so many things fall through the cracks. We weren’t aware many of our friends whom we don’t see often had serious significant others and were happy to invite them. (Those who had been dating for two weeks were another story.) Unless your friend is much stronger than I, then she is juggling a thousand things and just may not have thought about it. Be polite (“totally fine if not”) but just ask. Can you tell my wedding is in one week? Send prayers. And anxiety meds.
· I’d want to be asked thusly: “Thanks for the invite! Are people bringing their boyfriends?”
· I was glad my groomsman asked for a plus-one. I had kind of fallen out of touch with “Joan” from my core group of college friends, and costs and space were issues for us. We knew she had just gotten engaged, and we hadn’t met her fiance, so we reluctantly decided not to invite them. Then the groomsman called and asked me what we’d think of him bringing Joan as his plus-one, and we jumped at it. Plus, 25 years later, we live near Joan and her now-husband and see them on an occasional basis, which is nice.
More from Carolyn Hax
From the archive:
The affair is over, but he won’t let go, and maybe she doesn’t want him to
How much do you tell the kids about their narcissistic grandpa?
Boyfriend is ashamed of girlfriend’s weight. Is it time to breakup?
Stays at her daughter’s cluttered home crowd her comfort level
Atheist daughter-in-law seeks a blessing to request ‘No prayers’
Sign up for Carolyn’s email newsletter to get her column delivered to your inbox each morning.
Carolyn has a Q&A with readers on Fridays. Read the most recent live chat here. The next chat is June 16 at 12 p.m.
Resources for getting help. Frequently asked questions about the column. Chat glossary