Democracy Dies in Darkness

WorldViews | Analysis

Putin says he wishes the Soviet Union had not collapsed. Many Russians agree.

By Adam Taylor

March 3, 2018 at 1:18 PM

Russian President Vladimir Putin participates in a forum of regional and local media organized by the Russian Popular Front in Kaliningrad, Russia. (Alexei Druzhinin/Pool/EPA)

A day after unveiling dramatic new weapons — including a nuclear-powered cruise missile — that sparked talk of a return to Cold War tensions, Russian President Vladimir Putin suggested that he'd reverse the collapse of the Soviet Union if he could.

Putin's comments on the 1991 fall of the U.S.S.R. — which bound Russia and many of its neighbors while exerting influence in Eastern Europe and abroad for almost seven decades — came at a question-and-answer forum held Friday in Kaliningrad. Taking questions from the audience, the Russian leader was asked what event in his nation's history he would have liked to change.

"The collapse of the Soviet Union," Putin responded, according to the Russian news agency Tass.

Though a fringe idea in the West, regret about the collapse of the Soviet Union is not unusual in Russia — in fact, it is widespread. And with Russian elections just a week away, it's a factor still worth watching.

The polling agency Levada Center has been asking Russians about their views on the collapse of the Soviet Union since 1992. The most recent numbers, from a survey conducted in November 2017, show that 58 percent of Russians regret the U.S.S.R.'s collapse, while just over a quarter do not.

Despite all the changes in Russia over the past quarter-century, this public regret has proved remarkably consistent. Only once since polling began has the number of Russians saying they had regrets fallen below a majority — in December 2012, when 49 percent said they had regrets, though only 35 percent said they did not.

The pro-Soviet sentiment peaked in 2000, just as Putin was coming to power, when three-quarters of the country said they regretted the collapse.

This sentiment is understandable when events are viewed from the perspective of the average Russian. Though the end of the Soviet Union heralded the end of the Cold War tensions with the United States and its allies, for many, it was the start of years of political and economic uncertainty, as well as a diminished place for the Russian people on the world stage.

Watch more!
In his annual state-of-the-nation address, Russian President Vladimir Putin announced March 1 Russia had successfully tested new nuclear-powered weapons that could avoid any missile defense systems. (Reuters)

Part of the regret may be from the chaotic manner in which the Soviet Union came to an end. The last Soviet leader, Mikhail Gorbachev, said in 2016 that the end of the union was due to "treachery." Putin, formerly a KGB officer stationed in East Germany, called the breakdown of the U.S.S.R. the “greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the century” in 2005, pointing to how many Russian citizens wound up outside of Russian territory.

But the sentiment appears broader than that: The Levada Center's polling found that a majority of Russians felt bitterness over the end of the unified economic system, while a smaller group said they felt Russia was no longer a superpower.

Putin has been been leader of Russia in some form or another since 2000, making him the longest-serving Kremlin leader since Joseph Stalin. This week, Putin used his annual address to announce new weapon technologies that he dubbed "invincible," including nuclear-powered missiles that would be difficult for conventional missile defense systems to combat.

Thursday's speech marked a new low in U.S.-Russia relations in the post-Cold War period, experts argue. Some analysts say that while Russia already had weapons that could overwhelm U.S. missile defenses if needed, the public announcement of these high-tech weapons was probably designed to rally a domestic base ahead of the March 18 election.

Putin is expected to win easily next weekend, with a poll conducted last week giving him almost 70 percent of the vote — nearly 10 times the share for his nearest rival, a candidate from the Communist Party.

Despite his regret about the collapse of the Soviet Union, Putin told the audience on Friday that he wouldn't want to live in any other period than the present. Asked about his dreams for the future, the Russian president said: "I want our country to be successful, powerful, stable, balanced and looking ahead."

More on WorldViews

Putin’s new missiles could probably strike the U.S. The old ones could, too.


Adam Taylor writes about foreign affairs for The Washington Post. Originally from London, he studied at the University of Manchester and Columbia University.

Post Recommends
Outbrain

WorldViews | Analysis

Putin says he wishes the Soviet Union had not collapsed. Many Russians agree.

By Adam Taylor

March 3, 2018 at 1:18 PM

Russian President Vladimir Putin participates in a forum of regional and local media organized by the Russian Popular Front in Kaliningrad, Russia. (Alexei Druzhinin/Pool/EPA)

A day after unveiling dramatic new weapons — including a nuclear-powered cruise missile — that sparked talk of a return to Cold War tensions, Russian President Vladimir Putin suggested that he'd reverse the collapse of the Soviet Union if he could.

We're glad you're enjoying The Washington Post.

Get access to this story, and every story, on the web and in our apps with our Basic Digital subscription.

Already a subscriber?