Democracy Dies in Darkness

The Fix | Analysis

Democrats are twice as likely as Republicans to name Trump as a reason for their pick in congressional elections

September 17, 2018 at 7:00 AM

President Trump promises to be a key factor in November’s midterm elections — both because Democrats want to vote against him and Republicans want to vote to support him.

But the push and pull of the first two years of Trump aren’t equal, a new poll suggests.

Many polls have sought to gauge how Trump and a variety of issues are factoring into Americans’ voting decisions this fall, but a new survey finds interesting results using a different type of question: Asking voters who support Democrats or Republicans for Congress to explain “Why?” in their own words.

SurveyMonkey asked registered voters this question in late August, and teamed up with researchers at the University of Michigan and Georgetown University to dissect the responses, identifying the most common words voters used in explaining their support.

Across the nearly 5,000 reasons voters described, the findings relating to Trump are particularly striking. Trump was mentioned by about 1 in 7 voters, 14 percent. But there was a large gap depending on which party voters supported, with more than twice as many voters who support Democrats for Congress mentioning Trump as those who support Republicans, 21 percent vs. 9 percent.

Democratic voters' greater emphasis on Trump contrasts with results from a closed-ended question asking about Trump’s influence on voting in a similarly timed Washington Post-ABC News poll. That survey found 59 percent of voters overall saying it was “extremely” or “very” important to share a candidates' opinion on Trump, including similar shares of voters who support Democratic and Republican candidates (62 percent and 61 percent, respectively).

The SurveyMonkey poll also found Democrats and Republicans were much more likely to cite the opposite political party in explaining their support for Congress. Voters who support Republicans for Congress were 20 percentage points more likely to mention the Democratic Party in explaining their vote than the Republican Party (33 percent vs. 13 percent). Likewise, voters supporting Democrats were far more likely to mention the Republican Party than their own party (39 percent vs. 18 percent).

This suggests that, while Democrats see Trump as something to be voted against, Republicans also have their own boogeyman: The Democratic Party. And in politics, fear is often the most powerful motivator.

Even in many of their responses mentioning Trump, Republican voters cited the danger Democrats posed to him, rather than simply saying they love Trump.

“From my perspective, Democrats are in lockstep in the effort to remove Donald Trump from office by any means for reasons even they can’t clearly define,” said one Republican response that mirrored others.

Added another more bluntly: “Because liberals are nuts [and] Trump has improved the economy.”

The results are consistent with “negative partisanship,” the idea that with declining popularity of political parties, dislike or even antipathy for the opposite party is the biggest unifying force.

Reasons mentioned more often by Republican votersSupport Democratic candidateSupport Republican candidate 
Reasons mentioned more often by Democratic votersSupport Democratic candidateSupport Republican candidate 

That kind of thinking was prominent in many of the open-ended responses by Democratic-leaning voters.

"I am against almost everything Trump represents” said a 46 year-old from Illinois who supports Democrats for Congress.

But even among Republican-leaning voters, desires to support Trump’s agenda were mixed with criticism of Democrats. “Because Democrats are obsessed with hating Donald Trump and forgotten that there is a country to run, plus, Donald Trump and the R’s have gotten this economy back on stable ground and growing,” one respondent said.

The SurveyMonkey poll showed that even while most people don’t volunteer Trump in describing their vote, voters are paying an enormous amount of attention to him. Over two-thirds, 68 percent, of registered voters said they had heard “a lot” about Trump in the previous week, and another 19 percent had heard “a little,” with Democrats and Republicans reporting at similar levels.

Democratic voters talk about winning the House, while Republicans talk about ideology and the economy

While voters’ explanations of their support for Congress focused most on Trump and the parties themselves, those supporting Democrats and Republicans differed sharply in emphasizing or ignoring various topics.

Democratic-leaning voters were much more likely than Republican-leaning voters to mention the word “House” (7 percent vs. 2 percent) often referring to their desire for Democrats to take control of the House of Representatives. More Democratic voters also mentioned “check,” usually describing their desire for a check against Trump’s power as president (2 percent vs. almost no Republicans surveyed).

Meanwhile, Republican-leaning voters were more likely to mention political ideologies, with 9 percent of Republican-leaning voters mentioning “conservative” and 3 percent mentioning “socialism.” Few Democratic-leaning voters mentioned either term (2 percent of Democratic-leaning voters mentioned “liberal,” 3 percent of Republican-leaning voters did).

Republican-leaning voters were also somewhat more likely to mention two major campaign issues. The economy was mentioned by 4 percent of Republican supporters and 1 percent of Democrats, while Republican-leaning voters were also slightly more apt to mention immigration (2 percent vs. 1 percent). These differences are small and probably insignificant, but the relative silence among Democrats on these issues signals that they are not rallying cries for their supporters.

There’s little question that Trump is playing a major role in voters’ attitudes about the 2018 election. The latest Washington Post-ABC News poll found more than 8 in 10 voters who approve of Trump support Republicans for Congress, while more than 8 in 10 of Trump disapprovers support Democrats. Among independents, Trump approval is a strong indicator of which way voters are swinging.

But despite Trump’s omnipresence in the news, most voters don’t think of their own congressional vote as being, first and foremost, about Trump.

The poll was based on interviews with 7,997 registered voters nationwide Aug. 22-28, and included 4,997 responses to the question asking why voters supported a party’s candidate for Congress. The poll was conducted by SurveyMonkey among a sample of the millions of people who take an unrelated user-generated survey on the firm’s platform, a non-probability sampling method of all U.S. registered voters. Analysis of open-ended survey responses used unweighted data. See here for more on SurveyMonkey’s methodology.

The poll and analysis above are part of a collaboration between SurveyMonkey, The Washington Post and researchers at the University of Michigan and Georgetown University. Data collection and analysis were managed by Mark Blumenthal and Sarah Cho of SurveyMonkey, with design and analysis by Josh Pasek, Stuart Soroka and Michael Traugott from the University of Michigan and Jonathan Ladd of Georgetown.

Question wording:

If the election for the U.S. House of Representatives were held today, would you vote ... ? Options: Definitely for the Democrat, Probably for the Democrat, Leaning Democrat, Leaning Republican, Probably for the Republican, Definitely for the Republican, Would not vote.

Why? [Open-ended]

Scott Clement is the polling director for The Washington Post, conducting national and local polls about politics, elections and social issues. He began his career with the ABC News Polling Unit and came to The Post in 2011 after conducting surveys with the Pew Research Center's Religion and Public Life Project.

Emily Guskin is the polling analyst at The Washington Post, specializing in public opinion about politics, election campaigns and public policy. Before joining The Post in 2016, she was a research manager at APCO Worldwide and prior to that, she was a research analyst at the Pew Research Center's Journalism Project.

Aaron Blake is senior political reporter, writing for The Fix. A Minnesota native, he has also written about politics for the Minneapolis Star Tribune and the Hill newspaper.

Post Recommends

We're glad you're enjoying The Washington Post.

Get access to this story, and every story, on the web and in our apps with our Basic Digital subscription.

Welcome to The Washington Post

Thank you for subscribing