When my girlfriend and I first had sex, she assured me she was on birth control pills. I took her word for it and didn't give it a second thought. Several months ago, we decided to live together. I realized recently I had never seen her actually take the pill. We did a major cleanup of the medicine cabinet and bathroom closet. Birth control pills never made an appearance. I have no reason not to trust her, but the fact that I am unable to confirm the existence of these pills -- something she would seem to have no reason to hide, after all -- concerns me. Is there a way I can inquire about this without effectively accusing her of lying to me?
-- Wanting to Be Sure "Hey, are you still on the pill? We haven't talked about it in a while, and I've never seen you take one."
I have zero evidence to back this up, but I am nevertheless dead certain she will accuse you of accusing her of lying only if she is lying.
Well, kind of dead certain. But I do believe the first impulse of someone with nothing to hide will be, "Yeah, I leave them in my [wherever]." For what it's worth, she's more likely to keep them in a [wherever] that she won't forget, as opposed to burying them next to the aspirin, and that could easily mean they're in a desk or dresser or nightstand drawer.
In exchange for this last bit of reassuring information, I request that you please not use it to toss your whole dwelling in search of the mystery pills. Have the guts to ask difficult questions (ideally, before you move in).
I am 24 and dating a 34-year-old man. We have been together six months, and the relationship has moved very fast. I care a lot for him and trust him but I have some concerns. He is very friendly and flirts with many women, and occasionally goes out with them. It's always an old friend he happened to bump into. I am not jealous but I do have a problem because, after they go out, he'll inform me a few weeks later that he's no longer speaking to the woman because she's now in love with him, etc. And although I tell him that makes me uncomfortable, he makes it seem as though I am being insecure because I am so young. Am I being paranoid or should I believe my instincts, which are that he likes the attention and leads these women on?
If you're asking me to choose between your instincts and his story, congratulations, you win the steak knives and valuable parting gifts. They all fall in love with him? That goes in the Oh Please Hall of Fame. Even if that somehow managed to be accurate -- imagine the street value of his pheromones -- it hardly reflects well on anyone to be everyone's number one guy.
Regardless, I'd call this a choice between your instincts and his empty condescension. How stupid does he think you are? And when does excusing him become stupid? Besides, when you voice a thoughtful concern, you deserve a thoughtful response, not beside-the-point blame simply for being yourself.
Write to Tell Me About It, Style, 1150 15th St. NW, Washington, D.C. 20071, or email@example.com, and join Carolyn's live discussion at noon Fridays at www.washingtonpost.com/liveonline